Effects of different ball games on bone mineral density and directional asymmetry of upper and lower limbs in college students

doi:10.16359/j.1000-3193/AAS.2021.0043

Abstract

Abstract:

In order to explore the effects of different ball games on the bone density and directional asymmetry of upper and lower limbs, 210 subjects were selected, whose age is 20.12±1.02 years old, who are right handness unddivided into 7 groups: basketball group, volleyball group, football group, badminton group, table tennis group, tennis group and control group, 30 persons per group, each group had a balanced sex ratio, similar height, normal body fat and body weight. The training years of each ball group were 6-8 years old, while the control group had no professional training years. Bone mineral density and Directional Asymmetry (DA) were measured. The results showed that the Upper Limb BMD of basketball group, volleyball group, badminton group, table tennis group and tennis group was significantly higher than that of the left Bone mineral density and DA of upper and lower limbs were significantly different among different groups. The results also showed that the order of bone density of left upper limb was volleyball group > football group > table tennis group, tennis group and badminton group > control group, basketball group > table tennis group, tennis group and badminton group > control group. The order of bone density of right upper limb was tennis group > table tennis group, volleyball group and basketball group > football group > control group, table tennis group > badminton group> football group > control group. The order of bone density of left lower limb was football group > basketball group, volleyball group, badminton group, table tennis group and tennis group > control group. The order of bone density of right lower limb was football group > volleyball group, basketball group, tennis group, badminton group and table tennis group > control group, volleyball group > badminton group and table tennis group > control group The order of DA is tennis group > table tennis group, badminton group, basketball group and volleyball group, table tennis group > basketball group and volleyball group. The results suggest that ball games can improve the bone density of upper and lower limbs and cause the asymmetry of its direction. The reason may be related to the mechanical stimulation to the bone.

Key words: Ball games, College students, Upper and lower limbs, Bone mineral density, Directional asymmetry

CLC Number:

Q987

XU Yunliang. Effects of different ball games on bone mineral density and directional asymmetry of upper and lower limbs in college students[J]. Acta Anthropologica Sinica, 2021, 40(06): 1023-1031.

Figures/Tables 4

References 31

[1]	丁桂芝, 李榕, 张澈, 等. 武汉地区2886名健康人骨矿含量变化规律的研究[J]. 华中科技大学学报(医学版), 1993, 22(1):50-53
[2]	孙晓红, 詹国瑛, 孙建琴, 等. 补钙对大鼠峰值骨量形成和预防骨质疏松的作用[J]. 营养学报, 2001, 23(1):40-43
[3]	Valimaki MJ, Karkkainen M, Lamberg-Allardt C, et al. Exercise, smoking and calcium intake during adolescence and early adulthood as determinants of peak bone mass[J]. BMJ(Clinical research), 1994, 309(6949):230-235
[4]	Turner CH. Three rules for bone adaption to mechanical stimuli[J]. Bone, 1998, 23(5):399-407 pmid: 9823445
[5]	Remes T, Vaisanen SB, Mahonen A, et al. Aerobic exercise and bone mineral density in middle-aged finnish men:a controlled randomized trial with reference to androgen receptor, aromatase, and estrogen receptor α gene polymorphisms (small star)[J]. Bone, 2003, 32(4):412-420 pmid: 12689685
[6]	叶瑛瑛, 陈巧玲, 张春燕, 等. 阻抗力量训练对绝经后骨质疏松症患者骨密度、疼痛评分及关节功能的影响[J]. 中国妇幼保健, 2020, 35(14):2593-2595
[7]	王蓓蓓, 蔺雪莲. 健美操训练对女大学生跟骨密度及性激素的影响研究[J]. 重庆医学, 2015, 44(3):397-399
[8]	刘欣, 徐亮亮. 跑步和游泳对青春期女孩骨密度的影响[J]. 中国康复医学杂志, 2014, 29(9):834-838
[9]	王晓红, 周波, 王松涛, 等. 举重和中长跑男性青少年运动员的前臂骨矿状态[J]. 中国临床康复, 2005, 9(20):193-195
[10]	郭浩. 足球或排球运动对男性大学生不同部位骨密度的影响[J]. 中国学校卫生, 2019, 40(2):264-267
[11]	李凤栓. 中学生网球运动员上肢骨密度的不对称性及其增龄性变化规律[J]. 中国骨质疏松杂志, 2019, 25(6):758-761
[12]	Auerbach BM, Raxter MH. Patterns of clavicular bilateral asymmetry in relation to the humerus: variation among humans[J]. Journal of Human Evolution, 2008, 54(5):663-674 doi: 10.1016/j.jhevol.2007.10.002 URL
[13]	陈兴才, 李炎, 玉洪荣, 等. 广西少数民族成年女性骨密度的差异及年龄变化特点[J]. 解剖学报, 2018, 49(5):683-687
[14]	张萌萌, 毛未贤, 马倩倩, 等. 吉林省北纬43°地区20-80岁健康人群25(OH)D₃水平及其与Ca、P的相关性[J]. 中国骨质疏松杂志, 2015, 21(5):579-585
[15]	郑同军, 陈岚岚, 张旭, 等. 大学生跟骨骨密度的性别差异与运动效应研究[J]. 杭州师范大学学报(自然科学版), 2017, 16(2):213-218
[16]	李心天. 中国人的左右利手分布[J]. 心理学报, 1983, 15(3):268-276
[17]	高登发, 朱燕明, 官剑武, 等. 2100 例不同年龄组患者骨密度Z值检查结果分析[J]. 中国骨质疏松杂志, 2020, 26(3): 333-336+352
[18]	伍旭林, 朱伟民, 刘懋, 等. 正常质量中年人体脂含量与腰椎和髋部骨密度相关性研究[J]. 中国骨质疏松杂志, 2020, 26(6): 889-892+897
[19]	邓力军, 周高晋, 段蔚楠, 等. 自然绝经后女性体重、体重指数与骨密度的关系[J]. 浙江医学, 2020, 42(3):266-269
[20]	申泽薇, 孙至佳, 余灿清, 等. 中国成年人身高降低与跟骨骨密度的关联分析[J]. 中华流行病学杂志, 2020, 41(6):813-818
[21]	张海燕, 周群英. 低体重和肥胖儿童身体成分特点及脂肪肌肉含量与骨密度相关性研究[J]. 中国妇幼健康研究, 2017, 28(7):758-760
[22]	Valen LV. A study of fluctuating asymmetry[J]. Evolution, 1962, 16(2):125-142 doi: 10.1111/evo.1962.16.issue-2 URL
[23]	Wolff I, Van Croonenborg JJ, Kemper HCG, et al. The effect of exercise training programs on bone mass: a meta-analysis of published controlled trials in pre and postmenopausal women[J]. Osteoporos is International, 1999, 9(1):1-12
[24]	Frost HM. Why do marathon runners have less bone than weight lifters? A Vita-bio mechanical view and explanation[J]. Bone, 1997, 20(2):183-189 doi: 10.1016/S8756-3282(96)00311-0 URL
[25]	张元通. 少年篮球运动员和普通中学生身体成分及骨密度比较:来源一所中学的数据[J]. 中国组织工程研究, 2019, 23(3):341-347
[26]	高建娜. 不同排球运动水平男性大学生骨密度比较[J]. 中国学校卫生, 2018, 39(11):1718-1720
[27]	莫月红. 不同运动项目对女大学生骨密度和体成分的影响及相互关系的研究[J]. 浙江体育科学, 2014, 36(3):105-110
[28]	周勇. 运动锻炼防治绝经妇女腰椎L2-4骨质疏松的作用[J]. 中国运动医学杂志, 2003, 22(1):72-74
[29]	Martyn-St J, Carroll S. Meta-analysis of walking for preservation of bone mineral density in postmenopausal women[J]. Bone, 2008, 43(3):521-531 doi: 10.1016/j.bone.2008.05.012 pmid: 18602880
[30]	郭梁, 邹亮畴. 网球运动对男性青少年骨密度的影响[J]. 吉林体育学院学报, 2010, 26(4):67-69
[31]	Frost HM. Skeletal structure adapations to mechanical usage (SATMU): 1. Redefining Wolff’s Law: The bone mode line problem[J]. Anat Rec. 1990, 226(4):403-413 pmid: 2184695

组别/Groups	年龄/Age(a)	质量/Mass(kg)	身高/Height(cm)	体脂率/BF	BMI(kg/m²)	训练时间/Training years(a)
篮球/Basketball	20.06±0.97	66.84±4.17	178.62±4.41	(19.56±1.24)%	20.51±1.36	6.81±0.98
排球/Volleyball	20.11±0.85	66.38±5.01	177.91±3.32	(19.35±1.18)%	20.34±1.47	6.72±0.59
足球/Football	20.21±1.06	66.42±5.14	176.72±3.14	(19.61±1.32)%	20.75±1.56	6.91±1.01
羽毛球/Badminton	20.13±0.65	65.91±3.95	176.59±4.27	(19.22±1.40)%	20.29±1.17	6.94±1.12
乒乓球/Table tennis	19.96±1.13	65.83±4.28	176.52±2.96	(19.47±1.51)%	20.23±1.34	7.08±1.24
网球/Tennis	20.19±0.74	65.90±4.72	177.81±3.87	(19.17±1.58)%	20.17±1.31	6.67±0.52
对照/Control	20.21±0.48	66.14±4.09	178.24±3.19	(19.46±1.46)%	20.42±1.28	---
F值	0.317	0.672	0.521	0.348%	0.219	0.876
P值	0.195	0.119	0.136	0.181%	0.204	0.097

组别/Groups	年龄/Age(a)	质量/Mass(kg)	身高/Height(cm)	体脂率/BF	BMI(kg/m²)	训练时间/Training years(a)
篮球/Basketball	20.06±0.97	66.84±4.17	178.62±4.41	(19.56±1.24)%	20.51±1.36	6.81±0.98
排球/Volleyball	20.11±0.85	66.38±5.01	177.91±3.32	(19.35±1.18)%	20.34±1.47	6.72±0.59
足球/Football	20.21±1.06	66.42±5.14	176.72±3.14	(19.61±1.32)%	20.75±1.56	6.91±1.01
羽毛球/Badminton	20.13±0.65	65.91±3.95	176.59±4.27	(19.22±1.40)%	20.29±1.17	6.94±1.12
乒乓球/Table tennis	19.96±1.13	65.83±4.28	176.52±2.96	(19.47±1.51)%	20.23±1.34	7.08±1.24
网球/Tennis	20.19±0.74	65.90±4.72	177.81±3.87	(19.17±1.58)%	20.17±1.31	6.67±0.52
对照/Control	20.21±0.48	66.14±4.09	178.24±3.19	(19.46±1.46)%	20.42±1.28	---
F值	0.317	0.672	0.521	0.348%	0.219	0.876
P值	0.195	0.119	0.136	0.181%	0.204	0.097

组别/Groups	上肢/Upper limbs				下肢/Lower limbs
组别/Groups	男性/Male	女性/Female	t	P	男性/Male	女性/Female	t	P
篮球/Basketball	0.718±0.079	0.682±0.075	2.684	0.019	1.297±0.115	1.279±0.114	2.146	0.047
排球/Volleyball	0.749±0.086	0.691±0.084	3.172	0.001	1.293±0.129	1.281±0.132	2.173	0.044
足球/Football	0.711±0.081	0.689±0.085	2.451	0.021	1.339±0.131	1.321±0.135	2.144	0.047
羽毛球/Badminton	0.732±0.091	0.681±0.088	3.220	0.001	1.288±0.114	1.261±0.115	2.558	0.020
乒乓球/Table tennis	0.725±0.084	0.693±0.087	2.459	0.020	1.286±0.124	1.264±0.119	2.399	0.037
网球/Tennis	0.738±0.092	0.698±0.093	3.075	0.002	1.288±0.118	1.276±0.113	2.048	0.049
对照/Control	0.691±0.077	0.639±0.071	3.672	0.000	1.248±0.114	1.007±0.105	2.212	0.042

组别/Groups	上肢/Upper limbs				下肢/Lower limbs
组别/Groups	男性/Male	女性/Female	t	P	男性/Male	女性/Female	t	P
篮球/Basketball	0.718±0.079	0.682±0.075	2.684	0.019	1.297±0.115	1.279±0.114	2.146	0.047
排球/Volleyball	0.749±0.086	0.691±0.084	3.172	0.001	1.293±0.129	1.281±0.132	2.173	0.044
足球/Football	0.711±0.081	0.689±0.085	2.451	0.021	1.339±0.131	1.321±0.135	2.144	0.047
羽毛球/Badminton	0.732±0.091	0.681±0.088	3.220	0.001	1.288±0.114	1.261±0.115	2.558	0.020
乒乓球/Table tennis	0.725±0.084	0.693±0.087	2.459	0.020	1.286±0.124	1.264±0.119	2.399	0.037
网球/Tennis	0.738±0.092	0.698±0.093	3.075	0.002	1.288±0.118	1.276±0.113	2.048	0.049
对照/Control	0.691±0.077	0.639±0.071	3.672	0.000	1.248±0.114	1.007±0.105	2.212	0.042

组别/Groups	上肢/Upper limbs				下肢/Lower limbs
组别/Groups	左侧/Left	右侧/Right	t	P	左侧/Left	右侧/Right	t	P
篮球/Basketball	0.695±0.081	0.741±0.083	-2.129	0.041	1.275±0.116	1.291±0.115	-1.315	0.184
排球/Volleyball	0.701±0.086	0.743±0.091	-2.035	0.043	1.273±0.132	1.294±0.144	-1.317	0.162
足球/Football	0.691±0.079	0.696±0.082	-1.713	0.097	1.306±0.126	1.357±0.135	-2.313	0.037
羽毛球/Badminton	0.681±0.078	0.739±0.082	-2.309	0.038	1.271±0.114	1.286±0.115	-1.312	0.187
乒乓球/Table tennis	0.684±0.083	0.745±0.085	-2.331	0.031	1.269±0.054	1.282±0.054	-1.312	0.191
网球/Tennis	0.682±0.079	0.757±0.088	-2.552	0.016	1.274±0.117	1.290±0.116	-1.313	0.186
对照/Control	0.661±0.063	0.665±0.067	-1.320	0.118	1.224±0.114	1.233±0.105	-0.997	0.217