人类学学报 ›› 2025, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (01): 78-91.doi: 10.16359/j.1000-3193/AAS.2024.0069
收稿日期:
2023-11-07
修回日期:
2024-03-06
出版日期:
2025-02-15
发布日期:
2025-02-13
通讯作者:
周亚威,教授,主要从事人类骨骼考古学研究。E-mail: zhouyawei469@163.com
作者简介:
王舒,博士研究生,研究方向为动物考古。E-mail: wsmercy@163.com
基金资助:
WANG Shu1(), WANG Chunxue1, ZHANG Xiangyu2, ZHOU Yawei3(
)
Received:
2023-11-07
Revised:
2024-03-06
Online:
2025-02-15
Published:
2025-02-13
摘要:
北沈家桥墓地坐落于陕西省西安市雁塔区,乃是分布于关中平原的一处战国时期的秦人墓地。研究表明:北沈家桥组具有以中颅型、高颅型与狭颅型相结合为主,呈偏阔面型,上颌中门齿多为铲形等特征;相较于亚洲蒙古人种各近代组,北沈家桥组与抚顺组等关系紧密,与蒙古组等较为疏远,应归属于东亚蒙古人种。与先秦早期古代组相较,北沈家桥组和仰韶合并组等“古中原类型”居民关系密切,与庙子沟组等“古华北类型”居民也相对相近;与青铜-早期铁器时代古代组对比,其与中小墓2组等殷商群体,以及湾李组、瓦窑沟组等秦、周人群体关系紧密。鉴于长时段内北沈家桥居民与黄河中下游居民在人种学上存在密切联系,尤其与殷商群体关系更为接近,结合文献考证等多学科证据,推测秦人或许为殷商群体的部族之一,进而印证了“东来说”。
中图分类号:
王舒, 王春雪, 张翔宇, 周亚威. 西安北沈家桥墓地人颅骨的形态及其族源[J]. 人类学学报, 2025, 44(01): 78-91.
WANG Shu, WANG Chunxue, ZHANG Xiangyu, ZHOU Yawei. Skull morphology and ethnic origin of the people from the Beishenjiaqiao cemetery in Xi’an[J]. Acta Anthropologica Sinica, 2025, 44(01): 78-91.
图1 西安北沈家桥墓地及部分发现 a.北沈家桥墓地位置Location of Beishenjiaqiao Cemetery;b.发掘现场航拍图Aerial photograph of excavation site;c.头箱内随葬的陶器Pottery buried in the headbox;d.铜剑Bronze sword;e.屈肢葬Flexed burial
Fig.1 The Beishenjiaqiao cemetery in Xi’an and some discoveries
马丁号No. | 测量项目Measurement item | 男性Male | 平均值Mean | 女性Female | 平均值Mean |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 颅长Maximum cranial length (mm) | 45 | 183.52 | 17 | 174.94 |
8 | 颅宽Maximum cranial breadth (mm) | 44 | 143.01 | 16 | 137.50 |
17 | 颅高Basi-bregmatic height (mm) | 39 | 140.88 | 14 | 136.50 |
9 | 额骨最小宽Minimum frontal breadth (mm) | 45 | 93.30 | 17 | 90.22 |
45 | 面宽/颧点间宽Bizygomatic breadth (mm) | 26 | 137.83 | 6 | 132.00 |
48 | 上面高Upper facial height (mm) | 42 | 72.72 | 15 | 69.47 |
52 | 眶高Orbital height (mm) | 44 | 33.10 | 17 | 33.20 |
51 | 眶宽Orbital breadth (mm) | 45 | 43.21 | 17 | 41.71 |
54 | 鼻宽Nasal breadth (mm) | 40 | 26.13 | 16 | 25.73 |
55 | 鼻高Nasal height (mm) | 43 | 52.27 | 16 | 49.55 |
72 | 总面角Total facial angle | 42 | 84.68° | 15 | 85.00° |
8:1 | 颅指数Cranial index | 43 | 77.87% | 16 | 78.50% |
17:1 | 颅长高指数Cranial length-height index | 39 | 76.76% | 14 | 77.97% |
17:8 | 颅宽高指数Cranial breadth-height index | 38 | 99.09% | 13 | 99.03% |
9:8 | 额宽指数Transversal frontoparietal index | 43 | 65.43% | 16 | 65.82% |
48:45 | 上面指数Upper facial index | 25 | 52.60% | 6 | 53.42% |
52:51 | 眶指数Orbital index | 44 | 76.61% | 17 | 79.69% |
54:55 | 鼻指数Nasal index | 37 | 49.82% | 16 | 52.11% |
表1 北沈家桥组颅骨部分测量值
Tab.1 Measurements of skull of Beishenjiaqiao group
马丁号No. | 测量项目Measurement item | 男性Male | 平均值Mean | 女性Female | 平均值Mean |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 颅长Maximum cranial length (mm) | 45 | 183.52 | 17 | 174.94 |
8 | 颅宽Maximum cranial breadth (mm) | 44 | 143.01 | 16 | 137.50 |
17 | 颅高Basi-bregmatic height (mm) | 39 | 140.88 | 14 | 136.50 |
9 | 额骨最小宽Minimum frontal breadth (mm) | 45 | 93.30 | 17 | 90.22 |
45 | 面宽/颧点间宽Bizygomatic breadth (mm) | 26 | 137.83 | 6 | 132.00 |
48 | 上面高Upper facial height (mm) | 42 | 72.72 | 15 | 69.47 |
52 | 眶高Orbital height (mm) | 44 | 33.10 | 17 | 33.20 |
51 | 眶宽Orbital breadth (mm) | 45 | 43.21 | 17 | 41.71 |
54 | 鼻宽Nasal breadth (mm) | 40 | 26.13 | 16 | 25.73 |
55 | 鼻高Nasal height (mm) | 43 | 52.27 | 16 | 49.55 |
72 | 总面角Total facial angle | 42 | 84.68° | 15 | 85.00° |
8:1 | 颅指数Cranial index | 43 | 77.87% | 16 | 78.50% |
17:1 | 颅长高指数Cranial length-height index | 39 | 76.76% | 14 | 77.97% |
17:8 | 颅宽高指数Cranial breadth-height index | 38 | 99.09% | 13 | 99.03% |
9:8 | 额宽指数Transversal frontoparietal index | 43 | 65.43% | 16 | 65.82% |
48:45 | 上面指数Upper facial index | 25 | 52.60% | 6 | 53.42% |
52:51 | 眶指数Orbital index | 44 | 76.61% | 17 | 79.69% |
54:55 | 鼻指数Nasal index | 37 | 49.82% | 16 | 52.11% |
项目Items | 北沈组BSJQ | 华北组N China | 华南组S China | 蒙古组Mongolian | 因纽特组Inuit | 抚顺组Fushun | 通古斯组Turgus | 藏族A组Zang A | 同种系标准差SD |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
颅长L of Maximum cranial(mm) | 183.52 | 178.50 | 179.90 | 182.20 | 182.30 | 180.80 | 185.50 | 174.80 | 5.73 |
颅宽b of Maximum cranial(mm) | 143.01 | 138.20 | 140.90 | 149.00 | 141.20 | 139.70 | 145.70 | 139.40 | 4.76 |
颅高Basi-bregmatic height (mm) | 140.88 | 137.20 | 137.80 | 131.40 | 135.20 | 139.20 | 126.30 | 131.20 | 5.69 |
最小额宽b of Minimum frontal(mm) | 93.30 | 89.40 | 91.50 | 94.30 | 94.90 | 90.80 | 90.60 | 92.60 | 4.05 |
面宽Bizygomatic breadth | 137.83 | 132.70 | 132.60 | 141.80 | 138.40 | 134.30 | 141.60 | 130.40 | 4.57 |
上面高Upper facial height (mm) | 72.72 | 75.30 | 73.80 | 78.00 | 77.60 | 76.20 | 75.40 | 69.40 | 4.15 |
鼻宽Nasal breadth (mm) | 26.13 | 25.00 | 25.25 | 27.40 | 24.40 | 25.70 | 27.10 | 25.70 | 1.77 |
鼻高Nasal height (mm) | 52.27 | 55.30 | 52.60 | 56.50 | 54.60 | 55.10 | 55.30 | 51.00 | 2.92 |
眶宽Orbital breadth (mm) | 43.21 | 44.00 | 42.10 | 43.20 | 43.40 | 42.90 | 43.00 | 41.50 | 1.67 |
眶高Orbital height (mm) | 33.10 | 35.50 | 34.60 | 35.80 | 36.10 | 35.50 | 35.00 | 35.00 | 1.91 |
总面角Facial angle | 84.68° | 83.39° | 84.70° | 87.50° | 83.80° | 83.60° | 86.60° | 87.40° | 3.24 |
颅指数Cranial index | 77.87% | 77.56% | 78.75% | 82.00% | 77.40% | 77.30% | 78.70% | 79.80% | 2.67 |
颅长高指数I of Cranial h/L | 76.76% | 77.02% | 77.02% | 72.12% | 74.26% | 77.10% | 68.09% | 75.10% | 2.94 |
颅宽高指数I of Cranial h/b | 99.09% | 99.53% | 97.80% | 88.19% | 95.95% | 100% | 86.69% | 94.10% | 4.30 |
额宽指数I of Transversal frontoparietal | 65.43% | 64.69% | 64.94% | 63.29% | 67.46% | 65.00% | 62.18% | 66.60% | 3.29 |
上面指数I of Upper face | 52.60% | 56.80% | 55.70% | 55.01% | 56.07% | 56.80% | 53.25% | 53.70% | 3.30 |
鼻指数I of Nasal | 49.82% | 45.33% | 48.50% | 48.60% | 44.69% | 46.90% | 49.40% | 50.40% | 3.82 |
眶指数I of Orbital | 76.61% | 80.66% | 89.35% | 82.90% | 83.00% | 83.00% | 81.50% | 84.20% | 5.05 |
表2 北沈家桥组与亚洲蒙古人种各近代组的比较(男性)
Tab.2 Comparison between Beishenjiaqiao group and relative groups of modern Asiatic Mongoloid (male)
项目Items | 北沈组BSJQ | 华北组N China | 华南组S China | 蒙古组Mongolian | 因纽特组Inuit | 抚顺组Fushun | 通古斯组Turgus | 藏族A组Zang A | 同种系标准差SD |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
颅长L of Maximum cranial(mm) | 183.52 | 178.50 | 179.90 | 182.20 | 182.30 | 180.80 | 185.50 | 174.80 | 5.73 |
颅宽b of Maximum cranial(mm) | 143.01 | 138.20 | 140.90 | 149.00 | 141.20 | 139.70 | 145.70 | 139.40 | 4.76 |
颅高Basi-bregmatic height (mm) | 140.88 | 137.20 | 137.80 | 131.40 | 135.20 | 139.20 | 126.30 | 131.20 | 5.69 |
最小额宽b of Minimum frontal(mm) | 93.30 | 89.40 | 91.50 | 94.30 | 94.90 | 90.80 | 90.60 | 92.60 | 4.05 |
面宽Bizygomatic breadth | 137.83 | 132.70 | 132.60 | 141.80 | 138.40 | 134.30 | 141.60 | 130.40 | 4.57 |
上面高Upper facial height (mm) | 72.72 | 75.30 | 73.80 | 78.00 | 77.60 | 76.20 | 75.40 | 69.40 | 4.15 |
鼻宽Nasal breadth (mm) | 26.13 | 25.00 | 25.25 | 27.40 | 24.40 | 25.70 | 27.10 | 25.70 | 1.77 |
鼻高Nasal height (mm) | 52.27 | 55.30 | 52.60 | 56.50 | 54.60 | 55.10 | 55.30 | 51.00 | 2.92 |
眶宽Orbital breadth (mm) | 43.21 | 44.00 | 42.10 | 43.20 | 43.40 | 42.90 | 43.00 | 41.50 | 1.67 |
眶高Orbital height (mm) | 33.10 | 35.50 | 34.60 | 35.80 | 36.10 | 35.50 | 35.00 | 35.00 | 1.91 |
总面角Facial angle | 84.68° | 83.39° | 84.70° | 87.50° | 83.80° | 83.60° | 86.60° | 87.40° | 3.24 |
颅指数Cranial index | 77.87% | 77.56% | 78.75% | 82.00% | 77.40% | 77.30% | 78.70% | 79.80% | 2.67 |
颅长高指数I of Cranial h/L | 76.76% | 77.02% | 77.02% | 72.12% | 74.26% | 77.10% | 68.09% | 75.10% | 2.94 |
颅宽高指数I of Cranial h/b | 99.09% | 99.53% | 97.80% | 88.19% | 95.95% | 100% | 86.69% | 94.10% | 4.30 |
额宽指数I of Transversal frontoparietal | 65.43% | 64.69% | 64.94% | 63.29% | 67.46% | 65.00% | 62.18% | 66.60% | 3.29 |
上面指数I of Upper face | 52.60% | 56.80% | 55.70% | 55.01% | 56.07% | 56.80% | 53.25% | 53.70% | 3.30 |
鼻指数I of Nasal | 49.82% | 45.33% | 48.50% | 48.60% | 44.69% | 46.90% | 49.40% | 50.40% | 3.82 |
眶指数I of Orbital | 76.61% | 80.66% | 89.35% | 82.90% | 83.00% | 83.00% | 81.50% | 84.20% | 5.05 |
项目Items | 北沈组BSJQ | 仰韶合并组YS | 陶寺组TS | 庙底沟组MDG | 庙子沟组MZG | 姜家梁组JJL | 柳湾合并组LW | 菜园组CY | 昙石山组TSS | 甑皮岩组ZPY | 后套一期组HT-1 | 贝加尔湖新石器组BAI | 大汶口组DWK | 西夏侯组XXH | 呈子二期组CZ-2 | 尉迟寺组YCS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
颅长Maximum cranial length (mm) | 183.52 | 180.70 | 183.80 | 179.43 | 177.63 | 178.27 | 185.93 | 179.60 | 189.70 | 193.30 | 183.70 | 189.70 | 181.11 | 180.30 | 184.50 | 185.30 |
颅宽Maximum cranial breadth (mm) | 143.01 | 142.56 | 139.69 | 143.75 | 137.03 | 134.20 | 136.41 | 135.60 | 139.20 | 143.20 | 135.30 | 144.50 | 145.70 | 140.90 | 144.20 | 137.40 |
颅高Basi-bregmatic height(mm) | 140.88 | 142.53 | 142.67 | 143.17 | 140.93 | 138.10 | 139.38 | 140.10 | 141.30 | 140.90 | 138.30 | 132.40 | 142.89 | 148.30 | 144.30 | 144.50 |
最小额宽Minimum frontal breadth (mm) | 93.30 | 93.64 | 94.53 | 93.69 | 90.36 | 88.60 | 90.30 | 93.70 | 91.00 | 93.50 | 87.20 | 94.40 | 91.64 | 93.94 | 94.80 | 92.10 |
面宽Bizygomatic breadth (mm) | 137.83 | 136.37 | 136.37 | 140.83 | 136.64 | 135.63 | 137.24 | 131.20 | 135.60 | 138.00 | 134.36 | 141.00 | 140.56 | 139.43 | 136.90 | 133.80 |
上面高Upper facial height (mm) | 72.72 | 73.38 | 74.11 | 73.48 | 73.50 | 75.53 | 78.19 | 71.90 | 71.10 | 69.70 | 81.96 | 74.90 | 77.50 | 74.60 | 74.90 | 70.30 |
眶高Orbital height (mm) | 33.10 | 33.48 | 32.79 | 32.42 | 32.93 | 33.39 | 34.27 | 33.30 | 33.80 | 34.40 | 36.74 | 33.90 | 35.05 | 34.34 | 34.07 | 35.30 |
眶宽Orbital breadth (mm) | 43.21 | 43.41 | 44.80 | 41.75 | 43.93 | 44.41 | 43.87 | 40.50 | 42.20 | 42.60 | 42.75 | 42.20 | 42.82 | 44.22 | 44.07 | 42.63 |
鼻宽Nasal breadth (mm) | 26.13 | 27.56 | 27.23 | 27.31 | 26.23 | 27.04 | 27.26 | 25.80 | 29.50 | 28.30 | 28.93 | 25.90 | 27.45 | 27.66 | 26.20 | 27.70 |
鼻高Nasal height (mm) | 52.27 | 53.36 | 54.45 | 53.99 | 52.63 | 55.58 | 55.77 | 51.00 | 51.90 | 53.10 | 61.40 | 55.00 | 54.72 | 57.12 | 53.20 | 53.80 |
面角Facial angle | 84.68° | 81.39° | 84.86° | 85.75° | 82.33° | 82.59° | 89.21° | 93.30° | 81.00° | 84.00° | 83.00° | 86.30° | 83.61° | 84.38° | 85.80° | 85.80° |
颅指数Cranial index | 77.87% | 79.10% | 76.07% | 80.31% | 77.22% | 75.76% | 73.92% | 75.20% | 73.40% | 73.20% | 73.65% | 76.30% | 78.71% | 78.20% | 78.20% | 74.30% |
颅长高指数Cranial length-height index | 76.76% | 78.62% | 74.44% | 77.64% | 79.57% | 78.74% | 74.74% | 78.40% | 73.80% | 70.50% | 75.29% | 69.79% | 78.90% | 82.30% | 78.10% | 79.20% |
颅宽高指数Cranial breadth-height index | 99.09% | 99.41% | 101.16% | 99.47% | 102.95% | 102.33% | 100.96% | 103.80% | 99.50% | 97.90% | 102.22% | 91.63% | 98.10% | 105.30% | 99.50% | 104.80% |
上面指数Upper facial index | 52.60% | 54.58% | 54.18% | 51.86% | 53.68% | 55.71% | 57.60% | 54.90% | 52.50% | 50.40% | 61.00% | 53.12% | 56.20% | 54.10% | 54.70% | 52.50% |
眶指数Orbital index | 76.61% | 77.18% | 76.73% | 77.71% | 76.76% | 77.39% | 78.46% | 82.20% | 80.00% | 80.40% | 85.94% | 80.70% | 81.94% | 77.97% | 78.90% | 82.80% |
鼻指数Nasal index | 49.82% | 52.08% | 49.52% | 50.15% | 49.90% | 49.00% | 49.09% | 50.70% | 57.00% | 53.30% | 47.12% | 47.20% | 49.45% | 48.46% | 49.30% | 51.50% |
表3 北沈家桥组与先秦早期对比组比较(男性)
Tab.3 Comparison between Beishenjiaqiao group and early pre-Qin contrast groups(male)
项目Items | 北沈组BSJQ | 仰韶合并组YS | 陶寺组TS | 庙底沟组MDG | 庙子沟组MZG | 姜家梁组JJL | 柳湾合并组LW | 菜园组CY | 昙石山组TSS | 甑皮岩组ZPY | 后套一期组HT-1 | 贝加尔湖新石器组BAI | 大汶口组DWK | 西夏侯组XXH | 呈子二期组CZ-2 | 尉迟寺组YCS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
颅长Maximum cranial length (mm) | 183.52 | 180.70 | 183.80 | 179.43 | 177.63 | 178.27 | 185.93 | 179.60 | 189.70 | 193.30 | 183.70 | 189.70 | 181.11 | 180.30 | 184.50 | 185.30 |
颅宽Maximum cranial breadth (mm) | 143.01 | 142.56 | 139.69 | 143.75 | 137.03 | 134.20 | 136.41 | 135.60 | 139.20 | 143.20 | 135.30 | 144.50 | 145.70 | 140.90 | 144.20 | 137.40 |
颅高Basi-bregmatic height(mm) | 140.88 | 142.53 | 142.67 | 143.17 | 140.93 | 138.10 | 139.38 | 140.10 | 141.30 | 140.90 | 138.30 | 132.40 | 142.89 | 148.30 | 144.30 | 144.50 |
最小额宽Minimum frontal breadth (mm) | 93.30 | 93.64 | 94.53 | 93.69 | 90.36 | 88.60 | 90.30 | 93.70 | 91.00 | 93.50 | 87.20 | 94.40 | 91.64 | 93.94 | 94.80 | 92.10 |
面宽Bizygomatic breadth (mm) | 137.83 | 136.37 | 136.37 | 140.83 | 136.64 | 135.63 | 137.24 | 131.20 | 135.60 | 138.00 | 134.36 | 141.00 | 140.56 | 139.43 | 136.90 | 133.80 |
上面高Upper facial height (mm) | 72.72 | 73.38 | 74.11 | 73.48 | 73.50 | 75.53 | 78.19 | 71.90 | 71.10 | 69.70 | 81.96 | 74.90 | 77.50 | 74.60 | 74.90 | 70.30 |
眶高Orbital height (mm) | 33.10 | 33.48 | 32.79 | 32.42 | 32.93 | 33.39 | 34.27 | 33.30 | 33.80 | 34.40 | 36.74 | 33.90 | 35.05 | 34.34 | 34.07 | 35.30 |
眶宽Orbital breadth (mm) | 43.21 | 43.41 | 44.80 | 41.75 | 43.93 | 44.41 | 43.87 | 40.50 | 42.20 | 42.60 | 42.75 | 42.20 | 42.82 | 44.22 | 44.07 | 42.63 |
鼻宽Nasal breadth (mm) | 26.13 | 27.56 | 27.23 | 27.31 | 26.23 | 27.04 | 27.26 | 25.80 | 29.50 | 28.30 | 28.93 | 25.90 | 27.45 | 27.66 | 26.20 | 27.70 |
鼻高Nasal height (mm) | 52.27 | 53.36 | 54.45 | 53.99 | 52.63 | 55.58 | 55.77 | 51.00 | 51.90 | 53.10 | 61.40 | 55.00 | 54.72 | 57.12 | 53.20 | 53.80 |
面角Facial angle | 84.68° | 81.39° | 84.86° | 85.75° | 82.33° | 82.59° | 89.21° | 93.30° | 81.00° | 84.00° | 83.00° | 86.30° | 83.61° | 84.38° | 85.80° | 85.80° |
颅指数Cranial index | 77.87% | 79.10% | 76.07% | 80.31% | 77.22% | 75.76% | 73.92% | 75.20% | 73.40% | 73.20% | 73.65% | 76.30% | 78.71% | 78.20% | 78.20% | 74.30% |
颅长高指数Cranial length-height index | 76.76% | 78.62% | 74.44% | 77.64% | 79.57% | 78.74% | 74.74% | 78.40% | 73.80% | 70.50% | 75.29% | 69.79% | 78.90% | 82.30% | 78.10% | 79.20% |
颅宽高指数Cranial breadth-height index | 99.09% | 99.41% | 101.16% | 99.47% | 102.95% | 102.33% | 100.96% | 103.80% | 99.50% | 97.90% | 102.22% | 91.63% | 98.10% | 105.30% | 99.50% | 104.80% |
上面指数Upper facial index | 52.60% | 54.58% | 54.18% | 51.86% | 53.68% | 55.71% | 57.60% | 54.90% | 52.50% | 50.40% | 61.00% | 53.12% | 56.20% | 54.10% | 54.70% | 52.50% |
眶指数Orbital index | 76.61% | 77.18% | 76.73% | 77.71% | 76.76% | 77.39% | 78.46% | 82.20% | 80.00% | 80.40% | 85.94% | 80.70% | 81.94% | 77.97% | 78.90% | 82.80% |
鼻指数Nasal index | 49.82% | 52.08% | 49.52% | 50.15% | 49.90% | 49.00% | 49.09% | 50.70% | 57.00% | 53.30% | 47.12% | 47.20% | 49.45% | 48.46% | 49.30% | 51.50% |
图2 北沈家桥组与先秦早期古代组的分析比较 A.聚类分析图Cluster analysis map;B.第一、二因子散点图Scatter diagram of the first and second factors。 1.北沈家桥组BSJQ;2.仰韶合并组YS;3.陶寺组TS;4.庙底沟组MDG;5.大汶口组DWK;6.西夏侯组XXH;7.呈子二期组CZ-2;8.尉迟寺组YCS;9.庙子沟组MZG;10.姜家梁组JJL;11.柳湾合并组LW;12.菜园组CY;13.昙石山组TSS;14.甑皮岩组ZPY;15.后套一期组HT-1;16.贝加尔湖新石器组BAI
Fig.2 Comparison and analysis of the Beishenjiaqiao group and the early pre-Qin ancient groups
项目Items | 北沈组BSJQ | 马腾空组MTK | 湾李组WL | 瓦窑沟组WYG | 殷墟中小墓2组YX-2 | 白庙1组BM-1 | 夏家店上层组XJD | 毛饮合并A组MY-A | 殷墟中小墓3组YX-3 | 庙后山组MHS | 平洋组PY | 上孙家寨卡约组SSJZ | 李家山组LJS | 东灰山组DHS | 寨头河组ZTH | 井沟子组JGZ | 新店子组XDZ | 彭堡组PB | 殷墟中小墓C组YX-C | 前掌大合并组QZD |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
颅长Maximum cranial length (mm) | 183.52 | 182.55 | 179.85 | 181.33 | 184.03 | 185.38 | 181.19 | 182.04 | 187.18 | 192.80 | 190.54 | 182.70 | 182.20 | 176.70 | 176.66 | 184.43 | 173.80 | 182.20 | 183.03 | 187.58 |
颅宽Maximum cranial breadth (mm) | 143.01 | 143.70 | 141.53 | 140.08 | 140.13 | 139.88 | 136.20 | 142.02 | 142.67 | 144.00 | 144.60 | 139.90 | 140.00 | 137.63 | 140.94 | 147.88 | 153.27 | 146.80 | 138.71 | 145.29 |
颅高Basi-bregmatic height (mm) | 140.88 | 141.38 | 139.98 | 139.45 | 140.32 | 146.50 | 140.70 | 136.88 | 134.83 | 143.50 | 140.11 | 137.90 | 136.50 | 136.05 | 136.80 | 131.50 | 129.18 | 131.90 | 138.78 | 134.65 |
面宽Bizygomatic breadth (mm) | 137.83 | 137.68 | 136.43 | 136.33 | 133.08 | 136.50 | 133.75 | 134.64 | 145.40 | 145.30 | 144.90 | 136.10 | 138.60 | 133.33 | 131.27 | 143.67 | 142.08 | 139.80 | 137.03 | 138.60 |
上面高Upper facial height (mm) | 72.72 | 72.57 | 70.88 | 72.50 | 73.81 | 76.00 | 75.10 | 74.50 | 75.08 | 75.50 | 77.08 | 76.70 | 77.30 | 73.10 | 72.34 | 76.00 | 73.91 | 77.80 | 73.35 | 77.10 |
眶高Orbital height (mm) | 33.10 | 34.26 | 34.15 | 33.38 | 33.55 | 33.13 | 34.44 | 33.88 | 35.52 | 32.60 | 33.91 | 34.90 | 35.40 | 34.33 | 33.05 | 32.84 | 33.12 | 33.80 | 33.52 | 34.71 |
眶宽Orbital breadth (mm) | 43.21 | 42.01 | 43.54 | 41.92 | 42.43 | 42.80 | 42.80 | 43.85 | 44.88 | 44.60 | 43.74 | 42.00 | 43.20 | 42.40 | 40.93 | 43.34 | 44.38 | 42.60 | 44.00 | 43.44 |
鼻宽Nasal breadth (mm) | 26.13 | 26.90 | 26.66 | 26.38 | 26.99 | 26.30 | 28.08 | 25.97 | 28.96 | 25.90 | 28.90 | 26.50 | 26.70 | 26.30 | 26.84 | 27.66 | 27.12 | 26.80 | 26.96 | 28.05 |
鼻高Nasal height (mm) | 52.27 | 54.60 | 55.14 | 55.00 | 53.38 | 54.63 | 53.60 | 55.10 | 56.42 | 54.10 | 58.38 | 56.10 | 57.00 | 51.95 | 51.96 | 57.72 | 56.52 | 58.60 | 52.52 | 56.69 |
总面角Facial angle | 84.68° | 86.44° | 86.00° | 83.33° | 83.81° | 87.75° | 80.60° | 86.00° | 84.63° | 85.00° | 90.89° | 85.90° | 87.00° | 83.83° | 84.05° | 89.80° | 88.00° | 90.70° | 85.64° | 86.67° |
颅指数Cranial index | 77.87% | 78.90% | 77.47% | 77.25% | 76.50% | 75.32% | 75.06% | 78.10% | 76.27% | 74.80% | 75.89% | 76.70% | 76.93% | 78.39% | 79.88% | 80.39% | 88.13% | 81.10% | 75.70% | 77.54% |
颅长高指数Cranial length-height index | 76.76% | 77.92% | 78.64% | 76.90% | 76.09% | 79.09% | 78.26% | 75.54% | 72.08% | 74.50% | 74.09% | 75.70% | 74.96% | 77.01% | 77.81% | 71.76% | 72.80% | 72.40% | 75.70% | 69.25% |
颅宽高指数Cranial breadth-height index | 99.09% | 98.30% | 99.61% | 99.55% | 99.35% | 104.83% | 103.46% | 96.63% | 94.53% | 99.65% | 97.30% | 98.50% | 97.60% | 98.08% | 97.31% | 89.51% | 84.57% | 89.70% | 100.14% | 89.42% |
上面指数Upper facial index | 52.60% | 53.65% | 52.54% | 53.24% | 53.98% | 55.95% | 56.15% | 54.48% | 51.66% | 51.96% | 53.06% | 56.50% | 55.88% | 55.66% | 54.94% | 51.93% | 51.93% | 55.60% | 53.93% | 57.43% |
眶指数Orbital index | 76.61% | 81.11% | 78.75% | 79.87% | 78.59% | 77.43% | 80.48% | 77.41% | 79.32% | 74.94% | 77.77% | 83.00% | 82.02% | 81.16% | 81.02% | 75.88% | 74.71% | 83.10% | 76.14% | 79.84% |
鼻指数Nasal index | 49.82% | 49.80% | 49.40% | 48.21% | 50.98% | 48.15% | 52.43% | 47.21% | 51.41% | 48.02% | 49.40% | 47.30% | 47.01% | 50.63% | 51.43% | 47.99% | 48.06% | 46.20% | 51.56% | 50.15% |
表4 北沈家桥组与青铜-早期铁器时期对比组比较(男性)
Tab.4 Comparison between Beishenjiaqiao group and the Bronze-early Iron Age contrast groups(male)
项目Items | 北沈组BSJQ | 马腾空组MTK | 湾李组WL | 瓦窑沟组WYG | 殷墟中小墓2组YX-2 | 白庙1组BM-1 | 夏家店上层组XJD | 毛饮合并A组MY-A | 殷墟中小墓3组YX-3 | 庙后山组MHS | 平洋组PY | 上孙家寨卡约组SSJZ | 李家山组LJS | 东灰山组DHS | 寨头河组ZTH | 井沟子组JGZ | 新店子组XDZ | 彭堡组PB | 殷墟中小墓C组YX-C | 前掌大合并组QZD |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
颅长Maximum cranial length (mm) | 183.52 | 182.55 | 179.85 | 181.33 | 184.03 | 185.38 | 181.19 | 182.04 | 187.18 | 192.80 | 190.54 | 182.70 | 182.20 | 176.70 | 176.66 | 184.43 | 173.80 | 182.20 | 183.03 | 187.58 |
颅宽Maximum cranial breadth (mm) | 143.01 | 143.70 | 141.53 | 140.08 | 140.13 | 139.88 | 136.20 | 142.02 | 142.67 | 144.00 | 144.60 | 139.90 | 140.00 | 137.63 | 140.94 | 147.88 | 153.27 | 146.80 | 138.71 | 145.29 |
颅高Basi-bregmatic height (mm) | 140.88 | 141.38 | 139.98 | 139.45 | 140.32 | 146.50 | 140.70 | 136.88 | 134.83 | 143.50 | 140.11 | 137.90 | 136.50 | 136.05 | 136.80 | 131.50 | 129.18 | 131.90 | 138.78 | 134.65 |
面宽Bizygomatic breadth (mm) | 137.83 | 137.68 | 136.43 | 136.33 | 133.08 | 136.50 | 133.75 | 134.64 | 145.40 | 145.30 | 144.90 | 136.10 | 138.60 | 133.33 | 131.27 | 143.67 | 142.08 | 139.80 | 137.03 | 138.60 |
上面高Upper facial height (mm) | 72.72 | 72.57 | 70.88 | 72.50 | 73.81 | 76.00 | 75.10 | 74.50 | 75.08 | 75.50 | 77.08 | 76.70 | 77.30 | 73.10 | 72.34 | 76.00 | 73.91 | 77.80 | 73.35 | 77.10 |
眶高Orbital height (mm) | 33.10 | 34.26 | 34.15 | 33.38 | 33.55 | 33.13 | 34.44 | 33.88 | 35.52 | 32.60 | 33.91 | 34.90 | 35.40 | 34.33 | 33.05 | 32.84 | 33.12 | 33.80 | 33.52 | 34.71 |
眶宽Orbital breadth (mm) | 43.21 | 42.01 | 43.54 | 41.92 | 42.43 | 42.80 | 42.80 | 43.85 | 44.88 | 44.60 | 43.74 | 42.00 | 43.20 | 42.40 | 40.93 | 43.34 | 44.38 | 42.60 | 44.00 | 43.44 |
鼻宽Nasal breadth (mm) | 26.13 | 26.90 | 26.66 | 26.38 | 26.99 | 26.30 | 28.08 | 25.97 | 28.96 | 25.90 | 28.90 | 26.50 | 26.70 | 26.30 | 26.84 | 27.66 | 27.12 | 26.80 | 26.96 | 28.05 |
鼻高Nasal height (mm) | 52.27 | 54.60 | 55.14 | 55.00 | 53.38 | 54.63 | 53.60 | 55.10 | 56.42 | 54.10 | 58.38 | 56.10 | 57.00 | 51.95 | 51.96 | 57.72 | 56.52 | 58.60 | 52.52 | 56.69 |
总面角Facial angle | 84.68° | 86.44° | 86.00° | 83.33° | 83.81° | 87.75° | 80.60° | 86.00° | 84.63° | 85.00° | 90.89° | 85.90° | 87.00° | 83.83° | 84.05° | 89.80° | 88.00° | 90.70° | 85.64° | 86.67° |
颅指数Cranial index | 77.87% | 78.90% | 77.47% | 77.25% | 76.50% | 75.32% | 75.06% | 78.10% | 76.27% | 74.80% | 75.89% | 76.70% | 76.93% | 78.39% | 79.88% | 80.39% | 88.13% | 81.10% | 75.70% | 77.54% |
颅长高指数Cranial length-height index | 76.76% | 77.92% | 78.64% | 76.90% | 76.09% | 79.09% | 78.26% | 75.54% | 72.08% | 74.50% | 74.09% | 75.70% | 74.96% | 77.01% | 77.81% | 71.76% | 72.80% | 72.40% | 75.70% | 69.25% |
颅宽高指数Cranial breadth-height index | 99.09% | 98.30% | 99.61% | 99.55% | 99.35% | 104.83% | 103.46% | 96.63% | 94.53% | 99.65% | 97.30% | 98.50% | 97.60% | 98.08% | 97.31% | 89.51% | 84.57% | 89.70% | 100.14% | 89.42% |
上面指数Upper facial index | 52.60% | 53.65% | 52.54% | 53.24% | 53.98% | 55.95% | 56.15% | 54.48% | 51.66% | 51.96% | 53.06% | 56.50% | 55.88% | 55.66% | 54.94% | 51.93% | 51.93% | 55.60% | 53.93% | 57.43% |
眶指数Orbital index | 76.61% | 81.11% | 78.75% | 79.87% | 78.59% | 77.43% | 80.48% | 77.41% | 79.32% | 74.94% | 77.77% | 83.00% | 82.02% | 81.16% | 81.02% | 75.88% | 74.71% | 83.10% | 76.14% | 79.84% |
鼻指数Nasal index | 49.82% | 49.80% | 49.40% | 48.21% | 50.98% | 48.15% | 52.43% | 47.21% | 51.41% | 48.02% | 49.40% | 47.30% | 47.01% | 50.63% | 51.43% | 47.99% | 48.06% | 46.20% | 51.56% | 50.15% |
图3 北沈家桥组与青铜-早期铁器时期组的分析比较 A.聚类分析图Cluster analysis map;B.第一、二因子散点图Scatter diagram of the first and second factors。 1.北沈家桥组BSJQ;2.马腾空组MTK;3.湾李组WL;4.瓦窑沟组WYG;5.殷墟中小墓2组YX-2;6.殷墟中小墓3组YX-3;7.白庙1组BM-1;8.夏家店上层组XJD;9.毛饮合并A组MY-A;10.庙后山组MHS;11.平洋组PY;12.上孙家寨卡约组SSJZ;13.李家山组LJS;14.东灰山组DHS;15.寨头河组ZTH;16.井沟子组JGZ;17.新店子组XDZ;18.彭堡组PB;19.殷墟中小墓C组YX-C;20.前掌大合并组QZD
Fig.3 Comparison and analysis of the Beishenjiaqiao group and the Bronze-early Iron Age groups
[1] | 王玉哲. 秦人的族源及迁徙路线[J]. 历史研究, 1991, 3: 32-39 |
[2] | 王志友. 早期秦文化研究[D].博士学位毕业论文, 西安: 西北大学, 2007, 33-62 |
[3] | 史党社. 秦关北望:秦与“戎狄”文化的关系研究[D].博士学位毕业论文, 上海: 复旦大学, 2008, 1-7 |
[4] | 王建华. 体质人类学与古代社会研究的新进展[J]. 文物, 2011, 1: 43-50 |
[5] | 洪秀媛. 甘谷毛家坪沟东墓葬区出土人骨的研究[D].博士学位毕业论文, 西安: 西北大学, 2014, 59-60 |
[6] | 陈靓, 田亚岐. 陕西凤翔孙家南头秦墓人骨的种系研究[J]. 西部考古, 2008, 164-173 |
[7] | 王一如. 陕西西安马腾空遗址东周时期墓葬出土人骨研究[D].博士学位毕业论文, 长春: 吉林大学, 2019, 159-215 |
[8] | 周春茂. 零口战国墓颅骨的人类学特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2002, 21(3): 199-209 |
[9] | 周婧峰, 周春茂. 秦人族源之人类学信息[J]. 考古与文物, 2007, 6: 98-102 |
[10] | 邓普迎. 陕西临潼新丰秦墓人骨研究[J]. 文博, 2016, 5: 24-29 |
[11] | 高小伟. 临潼湾李墓地2009-2010年出土战国至秦代墓葬人骨研究[D].博士学位毕业论文, 西安: 西北大学, 2012, 53-55 |
[12] | 陈靓. 宝鸡建河村墓地人骨的鉴定报告[A]. 见:陕西省考古研究所(编著).宝鸡建河墓地[M]. 西安: 陕西科学技术出版社, 2006, 194-223 |
[13] | 吴汝康, 吴新智, 张振标. 人体测量方法[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 1984, 14-15 |
[14] | 邵象清. 人体测量手册[M]. 上海: 上海辞书出版社, 1985, 34-56 |
[15] | 郑宁, 胡雄, 薛晓光. SPSS 21统计分析与应用从入门到精通[M]. 北京: 清华大学出版社, 2015, 279-281 |
[16] | 薛薇. 统计分析与SPSS的应用[M]. 北京: 中国人民大学出版社, 2014, 129-134 |
[17] | 中国社会科学院历史研究所, 中国社会科学院考古研究所. 安阳殷墟头骨研究[M]. 北京: 文物出版社, 1985, 50-109 |
[18] | 李法军. 陶寺居民人类学类型的研究[J]. 文物春秋, 2001, 4: 8-17 |
[19] | 韩康信, 潘其风. 陕县庙底沟二期文化墓葬人骨的研究[J]. 考古学报, 1979, 2: 255-546 |
[20] | 颜訚. 大汶口新石器时代人骨的研究报告[J]. 考古学报, 1972, 1: 91-134 |
[21] | 颜訚. 西夏侯新石器时代人骨的研究报告[J]. 考古学报, 1973, 2: 91-126+130-141 |
[22] | 韩康信. 山东诸城呈子新石器时代人骨[J]. 考古, 1990, 7: 644-654 |
[23] | 张君, 韩康信. 尉迟寺新石器时代墓地人骨的观察与鉴定[J]. 人类学学报, 1998, 17(1): 23-27+29-32 |
[24] | 朱泓. 内蒙古察右前旗庙子沟新石器时代颅骨的人类学特征[J]. 人类学学报, 1994, 13(2): 126-300 |
[25] | 李法军. 河北阳原姜家梁新石器时代人骨研究[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2008, 88-141 |
[26] | 潘其风, 韩康信. 柳湾墓地的人骨研究[A]. 见:青海省文物管理处考古队,中国社会科学院考古研究所.青海柳湾[M]. 北京: 文物出版社, 1984, 261-303 |
[27] | 韩康信. 宁夏海原菜园村新石器时代墓地人骨的性别年龄鉴定与体质类型[A]. 见:宁夏菜园-新石器时代遗址、墓葬发掘报告[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2003: 349-357 |
[28] | 韩康信, 张振标, 曾凡. 闽侯昙石山遗址的人骨[J]. 考古学报, 1976, 1: 121-144 |
[29] | 张银运, 王令红, 董兴仁. 广西桂林甑皮岩新石器时代遗址的人类头骨[J]. 古脊椎动物与古人类, 1977, 15(1): 4-14 |
[30] | 肖晓鸣. 吉林大安后套木嘎遗址人骨研究[D].博士学位毕业论文, 长春: 吉林大学, 2014, 9-21 |
[31] | 陈靓. 瓦窑沟青铜时代墓地颅骨的人类学特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2000, 19(1): 32-57 |
[32] | 易振华. 河北宣化白庙墓地青铜时代居民的人种学研究[J]. 北方文物, 1998, 4: 8-17 |
[33] | 朱泓. 夏家店上层文化居民的种族类型及相关问题[J]. 辽海文物学刊, 1989, 1: 111-122 |
[34] | 张全超. 内蒙古和林格尔县新店子墓地人骨研究[D].博士学位毕业论文, 长春: 吉林大学, 2005, 64-77 |
[35] | 魏海波, 张振标. 辽宁本溪青铜时代人骨[J]. 人类学学报, 1989, 8(4): 320-328, 395 |
[36] | 潘其风. 平洋墓葬人骨的研究[A]. 见:黑龙江省文物考古研究所.平洋墓葬[M]. 北京: 文物出版社, 1990, 211-212 |
[37] | 韩康信, 谭靖泽, 张帆. 青海大通上孙家寨古代墓地人骨的研究[A]. 见:中国西北地区古代居民种族研究[M]. 上海: 复旦大学出版社, 2005, 1-190 |
[38] | 张君. 青海李家山卡约文化墓地人骨种系研究[J]. 考古学报, 1993, 3: 381-415 |
[39] | 朱泓. 东灰山墓地人骨的研究[A]. 见:甘肃省文物考古研究所,吉林大学北方考古研究室.民乐东灰山考古—四坝文化墓地的揭示与研究[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 1998, 172-179 |
[40] | 黄陵县旅游文物局, 陕西省考古研究院, 延安市文物研究所. 寨头河-陕西黄陵战国戎人墓地考古发掘报告[M]. 上海: 上海古籍出版社, 2018, 182-205+397-402 |
[41] | 朱泓, 等. 内蒙古林西县井沟子遗址西区墓葬出土人骨的人类学研究[A]. 见:内蒙古自治区文物考古研究所,吉林大学边疆考古研究中心(编).林西井沟子-晚期青铜时代墓地的发掘与综合研究[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2010, 297-298 |
[42] | 张全超(著). 内蒙古和林格尔县新店子墓地人骨研究[M]. 北京: 科技出版社, 2010, 1-115 |
[43] | 韩康信. 宁夏彭堡于家庄墓地人骨种系特点之研究[J]. 考古学报, 1995, (1): 109-127 |
[44] | 原海兵. 殷墟中小墓人骨的综合研究[D].博士学位毕业论文, 长春: 吉林大学, 2010, 143-145 |
[45] | 王明辉. 前掌大墓地人骨研究报告[A]. 见:中国社会科学院考古研究所.滕州前掌大墓地(上、下册)[M]. 北京: 文物出版社, 2005: 674-727 |
[46] | 刘思源. 东西之争:文献与考古视野下的赢秦族源探索[J]. 三代考古, 2021, 701-720 |
[47] | 蒙文通. 秦为戎族考[J]. 禹贡, 1937, 7: 17-81 |
[48] | 傅斯年. 夷夏东西说[J]. 国立“中央研究院”历史语言研究所集刊, 1933: 1093-1135 |
[49] | 俞伟超. 考古类型学的理论与实践[M]. 北京: 文物出版社, 1989 |
[50] | 韩伟. 关于秦人族属及文化渊源管见[J]. 文物, 1986, 4: 23-28 |
[51] | 刘庆柱. 试论秦之渊源[J]. 人文杂志, 1982, 200: 176 |
[52] | 赵化成. 寻找秦文化渊源的新线索[J]. 文博, 1987, 1: 1-8 |
[53] | 李学勤. 清华简关于秦人始源的重要发现[J]. 新华文摘, 2011, 22: 59 |
[54] | 梁云. 关于早期秦文化的考古收获及相关认识[J]. 中国史研究动态, 2017, 4: 39-43 |
[55] | 梁云. 论早期秦文化的来源与形成[J]. 考古学报, 2017, 2: 149-174 |
[56] | 汪洋. 藁城台西商代居民的人种学研究[J]. 文物春秋, 1996, 4: 16-20+22-24 |
[1] | 凌亮优, 孙战伟, 李楠, 成芷菡, 冉智宇, 何嘉宁. 陕西洛川月家庄墓地人类颅骨的形态学[J]. 人类学学报, 2025, 44(01): 66-77. |
[2] | 周亚威, 王煜, 侯晓刚, 李树云. 山西大同金茂园遗址人群颅骨的形态学[J]. 人类学学报, 2024, 43(02): 233-246. |
[3] | 贺乐天, 陈国科, 杨谊时. 甘肃五坝墓地人骨反映的史前人群变迁[J]. 人类学学报, 2024, 43(02): 247-258. |
[4] | 陈峰, 曾雨欣, 付昶, 张海龙, 王博, 肖小勇, 李海军. 新疆且末扎滚鲁克墓地二期居民的牙齿磨耗[J]. 人类学学报, 2024, 43(02): 273-286. |
[5] | 李海军, 杨筱雨, 赵钰洁. 人类颅骨厚度研究的概述与展望[J]. 人类学学报, 2023, 42(06): 827-841. |
[6] | 孙晓璠, 张全超, 牟萍媛, 杨及耘, 曹俊. 山西洪洞西冯堡清代墓地缠足女性的骨骼损伤和关节疾病[J]. 人类学学报, 2023, 42(02): 201-213. |
[7] | 李楠, 孙战伟, 赵艺蓬, 何嘉宁, 凌亮优, 成芷菡, 冉智宇. 年龄鉴定的转换分析法及其在月家庄墓地人骨中的应用[J]. 人类学学报, 2023, 42(01): 75-86. |
[8] | 贺乐天, 王永强, 魏文斌. 新疆哈密拉甫却克墓地人的颅面部测量学特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2022, 41(06): 1017-1027. |
[9] | 赵东月, 吕正, 邢福来, 苗轶飞, 陈靓. 统万城遗址出土人骨颅面测量性状[J]. 人类学学报, 2022, 41(05): 816-825. |
[10] | 李法军, 邱林欢, 赵晨, 盛立双. 天津蓟州区桃花园墓地明清时期缠足女性的足骨形变[J]. 人类学学报, 2022, 41(04): 674-685. |
[11] | 李咏兰, 宇克莉, 张兴华, 包金萍, 李翀, 郑连斌. 藏族的体质类型和人种学特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2022, 41(04): 698-711. |
[12] | 刘柯雨, 孙周勇, 孙战伟, 邵晶, 陈靓, 凌雪. 黄陵寨头河与史家河墓地人骨的碳氮稳定同位素[J]. 人类学学报, 2022, 41(03): 419-428. |
[13] | Francesc RIBOT Trafí, Mario GARCÍA Bartual, Alfredo José ALTAMIRANO Enciso, 王谦. 犬齿窝与人类中面部骨骼的演化[J]. 人类学学报, 2022, 41(02): 193-217. |
[14] | 杨诗雨, 张群, 王龙, 张全超. 新疆吐鲁番胜金店墓地人骨的牙齿微磨耗[J]. 人类学学报, 2022, 41(02): 218-225. |
[15] | 赵东月, 刘昊鹏, 杨磊. 沣西新城曹家寨清代墓地古人口学初步研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2022, 41(01): 11-22. |
阅读次数 | ||||||
全文 |
|
|||||
摘要 |
|
|||||