人类学学报 ›› 2025, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (01): 92-104.doi: 10.16359/j.1000-3193/AAS.2024.0068
收稿日期:
2023-08-08
修回日期:
2024-02-21
出版日期:
2025-02-15
发布日期:
2025-02-13
作者简介:
周亚威,博士/教授,主要从事人骨考古研究。E-mail: zhouyawei469@163.com
基金资助:
Received:
2023-08-08
Revised:
2024-02-21
Online:
2025-02-15
Published:
2025-02-13
摘要:
为探讨不同生业模式人群饮食结构差异在牙齿微磨耗上的表现,本文使用超景深显微镜对郑州汪沟遗址和大同金茂园遗址出土的79例个体的下颌第一臼齿颊侧面进行微磨耗形态观察。 结果显示,两组人群在臼齿微磨耗形态存在显著差异:以农业经济为主的汪沟组臼齿颊侧面条痕均数为36.95条,条痕均长为236.89 μm,水平与垂直平均条痕长度比值平均为120.89%;农牧混合经济下的金茂园组条痕均数28.26条,条痕均长262.55 μm,两长度比值平均为83.51%。相比金茂园组,汪沟组人群臼齿颊侧面微磨耗特征存在条痕长度短、密度高、两长度比值较高的现象,表明不同的饮食结构会造成不同的微磨耗形态。
中图分类号:
周亚威, 付清鑫. 中国古代农业与农牧人群臼齿颊侧磨耗条痕的形态比较[J]. 人类学学报, 2025, 44(01): 92-104.
ZHOU Yawei, FU Qingxin. Morphological comparison of buccal wear marks on molars between ancient Chinese agricultural and agr-pastoralist populations[J]. Acta Anthropologica Sinica, 2025, 44(01): 92-104.
遗址Site | 墓号 Tomb number | 性别Sex | 年龄Age(a) | 齿例 Teeth sample | 条痕数Striations(n) | 条痕均长Lm(Striation)(μm) | Lh/Lv | 磨耗等级Wear degrees |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
汪沟 | 2014M116 | M | 45± | RM1 | 37 | 272.68 | 145.97% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2014M91 | M | 36-40 | LM1 | 44 | 254.25 | 140.24% | 6 |
汪沟 | 2015M65 | M | 36-40 | RM1 | 37 | 242.63 | 127.10% | 4 |
汪沟 | 2015M51 | M | 36-40 | RM1 | 40 | 247.20 | 114.76% | 6 |
汪沟 | 2015G1(14) | M | 36-40 | RM1 | 38 | 266.00 | 141.32% | 6 |
汪沟 | 2015M125 | M | 36-40 | RM1 | 43 | 223.98 | 106.10% | 7 |
汪沟 | 2013M8 | M | 30± | RM1 | 35 | 270.10 | 142.47% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2013M59东 | M | 30± | RM1 | 31 | 219.23 | 84.77% | 4 |
汪沟 | 2013M50 | M | 30± | LM1 | 36 | 245.95 | 129.18% | 4 |
汪沟 | 2013M46 | M | 30± | RM1 | 39 | 259.23 | 123.14% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2013M26 | M | 30± | RM1 | 36 | 251.80 | 126.99% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2013M14 | M | 30± | RM1 | 40 | 258.78 | 135.67% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2014M121 | M | 30± | RM1 | 36 | 238.65 | 128.50% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015M57 | M | 30± | RM1 | 41 | 249.90 | 119.93% | 6 |
汪沟 | 2015M4 | M | 30± | RM1 | 43 | 264.33 | 95.03% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015M24 | M | 30± | RM1 | 38 | 259.83 | 105.47% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015-M1 | M | 30± | RM1 | 34 | 240.88 | 110.21% | 4 |
汪沟 | 2015M124 | M | 30± | RM1 | 31 | 217.73 | 140.91% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015M35 | M | 25-30 | RM1 | 40 | 248.25 | 127.11% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2013M66 | M | 25± | RM1 | 39 | 253.38 | 132.16% | 4 |
汪沟 | 2013M6 | M | 25± | LM1 | 29 | 218.65 | 98.56% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2014M82 | M | 25± | RM1 | 31 | 210.75 | 86.38% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2014M117 | M | 25± | RM1 | 44 | 191.03 | 120.42% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2014M108北 | M | 25± | RM1 | 41 | 257.35 | 124.51% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2015M52 | M | 25± | RM1 | 35 | 282.33 | 132.69% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2015M29 | M | 25± | RM1 | 32 | 259.35 | 140.27% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2015M136 | M | 25± | RM1 | 26 | 204.20 | 148.87% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2013M69 | M | 25± | RM1 | 32 | 208.62 | 121.92% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2015M97 | M | 24-26 | RM1 | 42 | 200.20 | 106.29% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2013M67 | M | 20± | RM1 | 29 | 227.15 | 128.41% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2013M28 | M | 18± | RM1 | 34 | 229.63 | 93.91% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2013M10 | M | 15-20 | LM1 | 27 | 179.98 | 114.29% | 1 |
汪沟 | 2015M95 | M | 15-20 | LM1 | 23 | 244.95 | 118.95% | 1 |
汪沟 | 2013M12 | F | 15-20 | LM1 | 30 | 207.43 | 86.49% | 1 |
汪沟 | 2015M133 | F | 15-20 | RM1 | 29 | 217.93 | 77.07% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2013M65 | F | 16-18 | RM1 | 31 | 213.43 | 113.96% | 1 |
汪沟 | 2015M127 | F | 18-20 | RM1 | 40 | 213.55 | 124.34% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2014M99 | F | 20± | RM1 | 49 | 272.53 | 153.57% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2013M98 | F | 20± | RM1 | 52 | 231.43 | 99.08% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2015M126 | F | 20± | RM1 | 46 | 284.80 | 125.11% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2015M20 | F | 20-25 | RM1 | 43 | 246.00 | 126.80% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2013M72 | F | 25± | LM1 | 35 | 270.33 | 117.50% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2013H202 | F | 25± | RM1 | 32 | 224.58 | 105.49% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2015M139 | F | 25± | RM1 | 37 | 228.70 | 117.27% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2013M44 | F | 27-28 | RM1 | 40 | 240.00 | 86.45% | 4 |
汪沟 | 2013M37 | F | 30± | RM1 | 41 | 235.25 | 145.02% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015M40 | F | 30± | LM1 | 38 | 231.25 | 130.49% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015M134 | F | 30± | RM1 | 37 | 215.43 | 95.49% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2013M68 | F | 30± | RM1 | 43 | 189.45 | 136.15% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2013M53 | F | 30± | RM1 | 39 | 192.38 | 131.03% | 4 |
汪沟 | 2013M58 | F | 36-40 | LM1 | 32 | 228.55 | 136.90% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015M64 | F | 36-40 | RM1 | 37 | 262.50 | 139.78% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015M23 | F | 36-40 | RM1 | 38 | 246.87 | 136.05% | 6 |
汪沟 | 2015M128 | F | 36-40 | RM1 | 34 | 226.38 | 116.57% | 7 |
汪沟 | 2015H35:3 | F | 36-40 | RM1 | 37 | 231.55 | 129.3% | 6 |
汪沟 | 2015H35:1 | F | 36-40 | RM1 | 46 | 256.48 | 127.52% | 6 |
金茂园 | DT6#M4 | F | 45± | RM1 | 29 | 246.08 | 85.21% | 6 |
金茂园 | DT1#M16 | F | 45± | RM1 | 30 | 250.28 | 80.00% | 6 |
金茂园 | DT北区M4 | F | 30-35 | RM1 | 29 | 275.67 | 61.27% | 7 |
金茂园 | DT1#M8 | F | 30-35 | RM1 | 25 | 254.80 | 72.11% | 5 |
金茂园 | DT1#M7 | F | 25± | RM1 | 29 | 280.55 | 77.69% | 3 |
金茂园 | DT1#M14 | F | 20-24 | RM1 | 28 | 258.75 | 72.44% | 3 |
金茂园 | DT6#M19 | F | 20± | RM1 | 26 | 242.40 | 90.04% | 2 |
金茂园 | DT6#M1 | F | 20± | RM1 | 35 | 296.00 | 100.51% | 2 |
金茂园 | DT1#M4 | F | 20± | RM1 | 28 | 297.13 | 80.44% | 1 |
金茂园 | DT1#M17 | F | 20± | RM1 | 27 | 265.73 | 75.21% | 1 |
金茂园 | DT1#M6 | F | 18± | RM1 | 35 | 351.83 | 87.22% | 2 |
金茂园 | DT1#M13 | M | 50-55 | LM1 | 32 | 293.43 | 87.67% | 6 |
金茂园 | DT6#M7 | M | 45-55 | RM1 | 39 | 240.40 | 72.87% | 5 |
金茂园 | DT6#M5 | M | 45-50 | RM1 | 24 | 185.70 | 77.86% | 4 |
金茂园 | DT11#M11(1) | M | 40-45 | RM1 | 18 | 285.10 | 84.47% | 5 |
金茂园 | DT1#M19 | M | 39-44 | RM1 | 22 | 208.15 | 91.74% | 4 |
金茂园 | DT北区M9 | M | 36-40 | RM1 | 23 | 247.90 | 95.92% | 4 |
金茂园 | DT4#M20 | M | 36-40 | RM1 | 30 | 230.38 | 107.39% | 4 |
金茂园 | DTM4 | M | 32± | LM1 | 24 | 261.35 | 81.48% | 3 |
金茂园 | DT4#M12 | M | 27± | LM1 | 33 | 253.55 | 76.80% | 3 |
金茂园 | DT北区M12(1) | M | 25± | LM1 | 18 | 169.75 | 86.89% | 1 |
金茂园 | DT1#M2 | M | 25± | RM1 | 40 | 356.30 | 86.24% | 2 |
金茂园 | DT4#M22 | M | 23± | RM1 | 31 | 290.80 | 89.32% | 1 |
表1 汪沟组与金茂园组下颌第一臼齿微磨耗条痕统计
Tab.1 Statistical table of buccal microwear of mandibular first molars residents in Wanggou group and Jinmaoyuan group
遗址Site | 墓号 Tomb number | 性别Sex | 年龄Age(a) | 齿例 Teeth sample | 条痕数Striations(n) | 条痕均长Lm(Striation)(μm) | Lh/Lv | 磨耗等级Wear degrees |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
汪沟 | 2014M116 | M | 45± | RM1 | 37 | 272.68 | 145.97% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2014M91 | M | 36-40 | LM1 | 44 | 254.25 | 140.24% | 6 |
汪沟 | 2015M65 | M | 36-40 | RM1 | 37 | 242.63 | 127.10% | 4 |
汪沟 | 2015M51 | M | 36-40 | RM1 | 40 | 247.20 | 114.76% | 6 |
汪沟 | 2015G1(14) | M | 36-40 | RM1 | 38 | 266.00 | 141.32% | 6 |
汪沟 | 2015M125 | M | 36-40 | RM1 | 43 | 223.98 | 106.10% | 7 |
汪沟 | 2013M8 | M | 30± | RM1 | 35 | 270.10 | 142.47% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2013M59东 | M | 30± | RM1 | 31 | 219.23 | 84.77% | 4 |
汪沟 | 2013M50 | M | 30± | LM1 | 36 | 245.95 | 129.18% | 4 |
汪沟 | 2013M46 | M | 30± | RM1 | 39 | 259.23 | 123.14% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2013M26 | M | 30± | RM1 | 36 | 251.80 | 126.99% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2013M14 | M | 30± | RM1 | 40 | 258.78 | 135.67% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2014M121 | M | 30± | RM1 | 36 | 238.65 | 128.50% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015M57 | M | 30± | RM1 | 41 | 249.90 | 119.93% | 6 |
汪沟 | 2015M4 | M | 30± | RM1 | 43 | 264.33 | 95.03% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015M24 | M | 30± | RM1 | 38 | 259.83 | 105.47% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015-M1 | M | 30± | RM1 | 34 | 240.88 | 110.21% | 4 |
汪沟 | 2015M124 | M | 30± | RM1 | 31 | 217.73 | 140.91% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015M35 | M | 25-30 | RM1 | 40 | 248.25 | 127.11% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2013M66 | M | 25± | RM1 | 39 | 253.38 | 132.16% | 4 |
汪沟 | 2013M6 | M | 25± | LM1 | 29 | 218.65 | 98.56% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2014M82 | M | 25± | RM1 | 31 | 210.75 | 86.38% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2014M117 | M | 25± | RM1 | 44 | 191.03 | 120.42% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2014M108北 | M | 25± | RM1 | 41 | 257.35 | 124.51% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2015M52 | M | 25± | RM1 | 35 | 282.33 | 132.69% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2015M29 | M | 25± | RM1 | 32 | 259.35 | 140.27% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2015M136 | M | 25± | RM1 | 26 | 204.20 | 148.87% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2013M69 | M | 25± | RM1 | 32 | 208.62 | 121.92% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2015M97 | M | 24-26 | RM1 | 42 | 200.20 | 106.29% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2013M67 | M | 20± | RM1 | 29 | 227.15 | 128.41% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2013M28 | M | 18± | RM1 | 34 | 229.63 | 93.91% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2013M10 | M | 15-20 | LM1 | 27 | 179.98 | 114.29% | 1 |
汪沟 | 2015M95 | M | 15-20 | LM1 | 23 | 244.95 | 118.95% | 1 |
汪沟 | 2013M12 | F | 15-20 | LM1 | 30 | 207.43 | 86.49% | 1 |
汪沟 | 2015M133 | F | 15-20 | RM1 | 29 | 217.93 | 77.07% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2013M65 | F | 16-18 | RM1 | 31 | 213.43 | 113.96% | 1 |
汪沟 | 2015M127 | F | 18-20 | RM1 | 40 | 213.55 | 124.34% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2014M99 | F | 20± | RM1 | 49 | 272.53 | 153.57% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2013M98 | F | 20± | RM1 | 52 | 231.43 | 99.08% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2015M126 | F | 20± | RM1 | 46 | 284.80 | 125.11% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2015M20 | F | 20-25 | RM1 | 43 | 246.00 | 126.80% | 2 |
汪沟 | 2013M72 | F | 25± | LM1 | 35 | 270.33 | 117.50% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2013H202 | F | 25± | RM1 | 32 | 224.58 | 105.49% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2015M139 | F | 25± | RM1 | 37 | 228.70 | 117.27% | 3 |
汪沟 | 2013M44 | F | 27-28 | RM1 | 40 | 240.00 | 86.45% | 4 |
汪沟 | 2013M37 | F | 30± | RM1 | 41 | 235.25 | 145.02% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015M40 | F | 30± | LM1 | 38 | 231.25 | 130.49% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015M134 | F | 30± | RM1 | 37 | 215.43 | 95.49% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2013M68 | F | 30± | RM1 | 43 | 189.45 | 136.15% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2013M53 | F | 30± | RM1 | 39 | 192.38 | 131.03% | 4 |
汪沟 | 2013M58 | F | 36-40 | LM1 | 32 | 228.55 | 136.90% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015M64 | F | 36-40 | RM1 | 37 | 262.50 | 139.78% | 5 |
汪沟 | 2015M23 | F | 36-40 | RM1 | 38 | 246.87 | 136.05% | 6 |
汪沟 | 2015M128 | F | 36-40 | RM1 | 34 | 226.38 | 116.57% | 7 |
汪沟 | 2015H35:3 | F | 36-40 | RM1 | 37 | 231.55 | 129.3% | 6 |
汪沟 | 2015H35:1 | F | 36-40 | RM1 | 46 | 256.48 | 127.52% | 6 |
金茂园 | DT6#M4 | F | 45± | RM1 | 29 | 246.08 | 85.21% | 6 |
金茂园 | DT1#M16 | F | 45± | RM1 | 30 | 250.28 | 80.00% | 6 |
金茂园 | DT北区M4 | F | 30-35 | RM1 | 29 | 275.67 | 61.27% | 7 |
金茂园 | DT1#M8 | F | 30-35 | RM1 | 25 | 254.80 | 72.11% | 5 |
金茂园 | DT1#M7 | F | 25± | RM1 | 29 | 280.55 | 77.69% | 3 |
金茂园 | DT1#M14 | F | 20-24 | RM1 | 28 | 258.75 | 72.44% | 3 |
金茂园 | DT6#M19 | F | 20± | RM1 | 26 | 242.40 | 90.04% | 2 |
金茂园 | DT6#M1 | F | 20± | RM1 | 35 | 296.00 | 100.51% | 2 |
金茂园 | DT1#M4 | F | 20± | RM1 | 28 | 297.13 | 80.44% | 1 |
金茂园 | DT1#M17 | F | 20± | RM1 | 27 | 265.73 | 75.21% | 1 |
金茂园 | DT1#M6 | F | 18± | RM1 | 35 | 351.83 | 87.22% | 2 |
金茂园 | DT1#M13 | M | 50-55 | LM1 | 32 | 293.43 | 87.67% | 6 |
金茂园 | DT6#M7 | M | 45-55 | RM1 | 39 | 240.40 | 72.87% | 5 |
金茂园 | DT6#M5 | M | 45-50 | RM1 | 24 | 185.70 | 77.86% | 4 |
金茂园 | DT11#M11(1) | M | 40-45 | RM1 | 18 | 285.10 | 84.47% | 5 |
金茂园 | DT1#M19 | M | 39-44 | RM1 | 22 | 208.15 | 91.74% | 4 |
金茂园 | DT北区M9 | M | 36-40 | RM1 | 23 | 247.90 | 95.92% | 4 |
金茂园 | DT4#M20 | M | 36-40 | RM1 | 30 | 230.38 | 107.39% | 4 |
金茂园 | DTM4 | M | 32± | LM1 | 24 | 261.35 | 81.48% | 3 |
金茂园 | DT4#M12 | M | 27± | LM1 | 33 | 253.55 | 76.80% | 3 |
金茂园 | DT北区M12(1) | M | 25± | LM1 | 18 | 169.75 | 86.89% | 1 |
金茂园 | DT1#M2 | M | 25± | RM1 | 40 | 356.30 | 86.24% | 2 |
金茂园 | DT4#M22 | M | 23± | RM1 | 31 | 290.80 | 89.32% | 1 |
图1 牙齿颊面微磨耗条痕的方向 注:H,水平方向Horizontal;MD,近中咬合面至远中牙颈方向Mesio-occlusal to distocervical;V,垂直方向Vertical;DM,远中咬合面至近中牙颈方向Distio-occlusal to mesiocervical
Fig.1 Schematic diagram of the direction of microwear striations on the buccal side
图2 超景深显微镜下部分牙齿颊侧面微磨耗条痕 注:2013M98,汪沟组样本Sample of Wanggou Formation;DT4M12,金茂园组样本Sample of Wanggou Formation
Fig.2 Microwear streaks on the buccal side of some teeth under ultra-depth microscope
样本量quantity(n) | 条痕均数 nm of Striation(n) | 条痕均长 Lm of Striation (μm) | Lh/Lv | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
WG | JMY | WG | JMY | WG | JMY | WG | JMY | |||||
青年组Youth group | 男性male | 4 | 1 | 28.25 | 31 | 220.43 | 290.8 | 113.89% | 89.32% | |||
女性female | 8 | 6 | 40 | 29.83 | 235.88 | 285.3 | 113.30% | 84.31% | ||||
合计total | 12 | 7 | 36.08 | 30 | 230.73 | 286.09 | 113.50% | 85.02% | ||||
壮年组Young adult group | 男性male | 23 | 4 | 36.13 | 27.5 | 239.59 | 260.24 | 120.93% | 82.85% | |||
女性female | 9 | 3 | 38 | 27.67 | 225.26 | 270.34 | 118.32% | 70.35% | ||||
合计total | 32 | 7 | 36.66 | 27.57 | 235.56 | 264.57 | 120.20% | 77.50% | ||||
中年组Middle adult group | 男性male | 6 | 7 | 39.83 | 26.86 | 251.12 | 241.58 | 129.25% | 88.27% | |||
女性female | 6 | 2 | 37.33 | 29.5 | 242.05 | 248.18 | 131.03% | 82.61% | ||||
合计total | 12 | 9 | 38.58 | 27.44 | 246.59 | 243.04 | 130.14% | 87.01% | ||||
整体overall | 男性male | 33 | 11 | 35.85 | 27.42 | 239.36 | 251.9 | 121.59% | 86.55% | |||
女性female | 23 | 12 | 38.52 | 29.18 | 233.34 | 274.47 | 119.89% | 80.19% | ||||
合计total | 56 | 23 | 36.95 | 28.26 | 236.89 | 262.55 | 120.89% | 83.51% |
表2 汪沟组与金茂园组牙齿颊侧面微磨耗统计
Tab.2 Statistical table of buccal microwear in Wanggou group and Jinmaoyuan group
样本量quantity(n) | 条痕均数 nm of Striation(n) | 条痕均长 Lm of Striation (μm) | Lh/Lv | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
WG | JMY | WG | JMY | WG | JMY | WG | JMY | |||||
青年组Youth group | 男性male | 4 | 1 | 28.25 | 31 | 220.43 | 290.8 | 113.89% | 89.32% | |||
女性female | 8 | 6 | 40 | 29.83 | 235.88 | 285.3 | 113.30% | 84.31% | ||||
合计total | 12 | 7 | 36.08 | 30 | 230.73 | 286.09 | 113.50% | 85.02% | ||||
壮年组Young adult group | 男性male | 23 | 4 | 36.13 | 27.5 | 239.59 | 260.24 | 120.93% | 82.85% | |||
女性female | 9 | 3 | 38 | 27.67 | 225.26 | 270.34 | 118.32% | 70.35% | ||||
合计total | 32 | 7 | 36.66 | 27.57 | 235.56 | 264.57 | 120.20% | 77.50% | ||||
中年组Middle adult group | 男性male | 6 | 7 | 39.83 | 26.86 | 251.12 | 241.58 | 129.25% | 88.27% | |||
女性female | 6 | 2 | 37.33 | 29.5 | 242.05 | 248.18 | 131.03% | 82.61% | ||||
合计total | 12 | 9 | 38.58 | 27.44 | 246.59 | 243.04 | 130.14% | 87.01% | ||||
整体overall | 男性male | 33 | 11 | 35.85 | 27.42 | 239.36 | 251.9 | 121.59% | 86.55% | |||
女性female | 23 | 12 | 38.52 | 29.18 | 233.34 | 274.47 | 119.89% | 80.19% | ||||
合计total | 56 | 23 | 36.95 | 28.26 | 236.89 | 262.55 | 120.89% | 83.51% |
图3 汪沟组与金茂园组牙齿颊侧面微磨耗统计 WYM—汪沟青年组男性;WYF—汪沟青年组女性;WAM——汪沟壮年组男性;WAF—汪沟壮年组女性;WMM—汪沟中年组男性;WMF—汪沟中年组女性;JYM—金茂园青年组男性;JYF—金茂园青年组女性;JAM—金茂园壮年组男性;JAF—金茂园壮年组女性;JMM—金茂园中年组男性;JMF—金茂园中年组女性
Fig.3 Statistical map of buccal microwear in Wanggou group and Jinmaoyuan group
遗址Site | 微磨耗形态Microwear patterns | F | T | Sig.(双尾) | 平均差MD | 标准差SD |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
汪沟Wanggou | 条痕均数Striations nm | 0.081 | -1.727 | 0.090 | -2.673 | 1.548 |
条痕均长 Striations Lm | 0.276 | 0.892 | 0.376 | 6.024 | 6.752 | |
Lh/Lv | 0.566 | 0.340 | 0.735 | 0.017 | 0.050 | |
金茂园Jinmoayuan | 条痕均数Striations nm | 11.237 | -0.554 | 0.586 | -1.348 | 2.436 |
条痕均长Striations Lm | 1.687 | -1.253 | 0.224 | -22.573 | 18.016 | |
Lh/Lv | 0.173 | 1.544 | 0.138 | 0.064 | 0.041 |
表3 汪沟组与金茂园组男女两性差异性两独立样本t检验
Tab.3 Statistical table of t test of two independent samples of gender difference in Wanggou Group and Jinmaoyuan Group
遗址Site | 微磨耗形态Microwear patterns | F | T | Sig.(双尾) | 平均差MD | 标准差SD |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
汪沟Wanggou | 条痕均数Striations nm | 0.081 | -1.727 | 0.090 | -2.673 | 1.548 |
条痕均长 Striations Lm | 0.276 | 0.892 | 0.376 | 6.024 | 6.752 | |
Lh/Lv | 0.566 | 0.340 | 0.735 | 0.017 | 0.050 | |
金茂园Jinmoayuan | 条痕均数Striations nm | 11.237 | -0.554 | 0.586 | -1.348 | 2.436 |
条痕均长Striations Lm | 1.687 | -1.253 | 0.224 | -22.573 | 18.016 | |
Lh/Lv | 0.173 | 1.544 | 0.138 | 0.064 | 0.041 |
条痕均数nm(Striation) | 条痕均长Lm(Striation) (μm) | Lh/Lv | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
M | SD | M | SD | M | SD | |||
WG1(n=12) | 36.08 | 9.55 | 230.73 | 28.60 | 1.13 | 0.21 | ||
WG2(n=32) | 36.66 | 4.48 | 235.56 | 25.57 | 1.20 | 0.18 | ||
WG3(n=12) | 38.58 | 4.06 | 246.59 | 16.39 | 1.30 | 0.12 | ||
JMY4(n=7) | 30.00 | 3.74 | 286.09 | 35.67 | 0.85 | 0.10 | ||
JMY5(n=7) | 27.57 | 6.70 | 264.57 | 54.79 | 0.77 | 0.89 | ||
JMY6(n=9) | 27.44 | 6.33 | 243.04 | 33.66 | 0.87 | 0.10 |
表4 汪沟组与金茂园组各年龄组间方差检验
Tab.4 Statistical table of variance test among different age groups in Wanggou Group and Jinmaoyuan Group
条痕均数nm(Striation) | 条痕均长Lm(Striation) (μm) | Lh/Lv | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
M | SD | M | SD | M | SD | |||
WG1(n=12) | 36.08 | 9.55 | 230.73 | 28.60 | 1.13 | 0.21 | ||
WG2(n=32) | 36.66 | 4.48 | 235.56 | 25.57 | 1.20 | 0.18 | ||
WG3(n=12) | 38.58 | 4.06 | 246.59 | 16.39 | 1.30 | 0.12 | ||
JMY4(n=7) | 30.00 | 3.74 | 286.09 | 35.67 | 0.85 | 0.10 | ||
JMY5(n=7) | 27.57 | 6.70 | 264.57 | 54.79 | 0.77 | 0.89 | ||
JMY6(n=9) | 27.44 | 6.33 | 243.04 | 33.66 | 0.87 | 0.10 |
图4 不同人群Lh /Lv平均值分布 HIN—印度人Hindu;WAN—汪沟人群Wanggou;WED—维达人Veddahs;JMY—金茂园人群Jinmaoyuan;AND—安达曼人Andamanese;TAS—塔斯马尼亚人Tasmanians;HMMH—哈民忙哈人群Haminmangha;JY—加依人群Jiayi;YH—洋海人群Yanghai;AUS—澳洲土著居民Australian Aborigines;BUS—布须曼人Bushmen;SJD—胜金店人群Shengjindian;FUE—智利土著居民Fueguians;INU—因纽特人Inuit;VAN—温哥华岛印第安人Vancouver Islanders;LAP—拉普兰人Lapps
Fig.4 Bar chart of mean Lh /Lv distribution of residents in different population
[1] |
Walker A, Hoeck HN, Perez L. Microwear of mammalian teeth as an indicator of diet[J]. Science, 1978, 201(4359): 908-910
pmid: 684415 |
[2] | Mills JRE. Ideal dental occlusion in the primates[J]. Dent Practit, 1955, 6: 47-61 |
[3] |
Ryan AS. A preliminary scanning electron microscope examination of wear striation direction on primate teeth[J]. Journal of Dental Research, 1979, 58(1): 525-530
pmid: 103950 |
[4] |
Pérez-Pérez A, Lalueza C, Turbón D. Intraindividual and intragroup variability of buccal tooth striation pattern[J]. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 1994, 94(2): 175-187
pmid: 8085610 |
[5] | Puech PF, Prone A. Mechanical process of dental wearing down by abrasion, reproduced by experimentation and applied to fossil man and his paleoecological surroundings[J]. Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Seances de l Academie des Sciences Serie D, 1979, 289(13): 895 |
[6] | Puech PF, Prone A, Albertini H. Mechanical process of dental surface alteration by non-abrasive and non-adhesive friction, reproduced by experimentation and applied to the diet of early man[J]. Comptes Rendus De L Academie Des Sciences Serie III-Sciences DeLa Vie-life Sciences, 1981, 293(9): 729-734 |
[7] | Puech PF, Albertini H, Serratrice C. Tooth microwear and dietary patterns in early hominids from Laetoli, Hadar and Olduvai[J]. Journal of Human Evolution, 1983, 12(8): 721-729 |
[8] |
Teaford MF, Walker A. Quantitative differences in dental microwear between primate species with different diets and a comment on the presumed diet of Sivapithecus[J]. American journal of physical anthropology, 1984, 64(2): 191-200
pmid: 6380302 |
[9] | Teaford MF. Dental microwear and diet in two species of Colobus[J]. Primate ecology and conservation/edited by James G. Else, Phyllis C. Lee, 1986, 386 |
[10] |
Teaford MF. Molar microwear and diet in the genus Cebus[J]. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 1985, 66(4): 363-370
pmid: 3993762 |
[11] | Lalueza C, Péréz-Perez A, Turbón D. Dietary inferences through buccal microwear analysis of Middle and Upper Pleistocene human fossils[J]. American Journal of Physical Anthropology: The Official Publication of the American Association of Physical Anthropologists, 1996, 100(3): 367-387 |
[12] |
Polo-Cerdá M, Romero A, Casabó J, et al. The Bronze Age burials from Cova Dels Blaus (Vall d′ Uixó, Castelló, Spain): An approach to palaeodietary reconstruction through dental pathology, occlusal wear and buccal microwear patterns[J]. Homo, 2007, 58(4): 297-307
pmid: 17675006 |
[13] | 张群, 周蜜, 张全超. 曾侯乙墓出土人骨的牙齿微磨耗形态研究[J]. 江汉考古, 2017, 6: 109-114 |
[14] | 张全超, 李墨岑, 张群, 等. 内蒙古哈民忙哈遗址史前居民牙齿微磨耗形态观察与研究[J]. 边疆考古研究, 2017, 2: 357-366 |
[15] | 张全超, 韩涛, 张群. 新疆鄯善洋海墓地出土人骨的牙齿微磨耗痕迹研究[J]. 西域研究, 2018, 3: 82-88 |
[16] | 张雯欣. 新疆吐鲁番加依墓地青铜—早期铁器时代居民牙齿磨耗研究[D].硕士研究生论文, 长春: 吉林大学, 2018, 25-27 |
[17] | 杨诗雨, 张群, 王龙, 等. 新疆吐鲁番胜金店墓地人骨的牙齿微磨耗[J]. 人类学学报, 2022, 41(2): 218-225 |
[18] | Price TD, Blitz J, Burton J, et al. Diagenesis in prehistoric bone: Problems and solutions[J]. Journal of Archaeological Science, 1992, 19(5): 513-529 |
[19] | 吴汝康, 吴新智, 张振标. 人体测量方法[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 1984, 11-25 |
[20] | 邵象清. 人体测量手册[M]. 上海: 上海辞书出版社, 1985, 34-56 |
[21] | 周亚威, 闫琪鹏, 顾万发. 郑州汪沟遗址仰韶文化居民的创伤研究[J]. 北方文物, 2020, 4: 67-72 |
[22] | 杨凡, 顾万发, 段绮梦, 等. 河南郑州汪沟遗址出土的植硅体[J]. 人类学学报, 2020, 41(3): 429-438 |
[23] | Sun B, Yang Y, Gu W, et al. Development of crop growing from the late Yangshao to early Longshan period in the Zhengluo region of central China: Phytolith evidence from the Shuanghuaishu site[J]. Vegetation History and Archaeobotany, 2023: 1-10 |
[24] | 周亚威, 张晓冉, 顾万发. 郑州汪沟遗址仰韶文化居民的牙齿磨耗及口腔健康状况[J]. 人类学学报, 2021, 40(1): 49-62 |
[25] |
周亚威, 周贝, 顾万发. 汪沟遗址仰韶文化居民的肢骨特征[J]. 解剖学报, 2020, 51 (1): 114-123
doi: 10.16098/j.issn.0529-1356.2020.01.020 |
[26] | 王煜. 山西大同金茂园墓地人骨研究[D].硕士研究生论文, 郑州: 郑州大学, 2021, 36-37 |
[27] | 侯亮亮, 古顺芳. 大同地区北魏居民生业经济的考古学观察[J]. 郑州大学学报, 2018, 51(6): 115-118+156-157 |
[28] | Zhang G, Hou X, Li S, et al. Agriculturalization of the Nomad-Dominated Empires of the Northern Wei Dynasty in Pingcheng city (398-494 AD): A stable isotopic study on animal and human bones from the Jinmaoyuan cemetery, China[J]. International Journal of Osteoarchaeology, 2021, 31(1): 38-53 |
[29] |
Gordon KD. A study of microwear on chimpanzee molars: implications for dental microwear analysis[J]. American journal of physical anthropology, 1982, 59(2): 195-215
pmid: 7149017 |
[30] | El-Zaatari S. Occlusal molar microwear and the diets of the Ipiutak and Tigara populations (Point Hope) with comparisons to the Aleut and Arikara[J]. Journal of Archaeological Science, 2008, 35(9): 2517-2522 |
[31] |
Schmidt CW, Remy A, Van Sessen R, et al. Dental microwear texture analysis of Homo sapiens sapiens: Foragers, farmers, and pastoralists[J]. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 2019, 169(2): 207-226
doi: 10.1002/ajpa.23815 pmid: 30888064 |
[32] | Romero A, Ramírez-Rozzi FV, De Juan J, et al. Diet-related buccal dental microwear patterns in Central African Pygmy foragers and Bantu-speaking farmer and pastoralist populations[J]. PLoS One, 2013, 8(12): e84804 |
[33] | Pérez-Pérez A, Bermúdez de Castro JM, Arsuaga JL. Nonocclusal dental microwear analysis of 300,000-year-old Homo heilderbergensis Teeth from Sima de los Huesos (Sierra de Atapuerca, Spain)[J]. American Journal of Physical Anthropology: The Official Publication of the American Association of Physical Anthropologists, 1999, 108(4): 433-457 |
[34] | Ungar PS. Mammalian dental function and wear: a review[J]. Biosurface and Biotribology, 2015, 1(1): 25-41 |
[35] | 何三纲. 口腔解剖生理学[M]. 北京: 人民卫生出版社, 2020, 239 |
[36] | Butler PM. The milk-molars of Perissodactyla, with remarks on molar occlusion[C]. Proceedings of the zoological Society of London. Oxford, UK: Blackwell Publishing Ltd, 1952, 121(4): 777-817 |
[37] |
Kay RF, Hiiemae KM. Jaw movement and tooth use in recent and fossil primates[J]. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 1974, 40(2): 227-256
pmid: 4815136 |
[38] |
Gordon K D, Walker AC. Playing’possum: A microwear experiment[J]. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 1983, 60(1): 109-112
pmid: 6869498 |
[39] | Puech PF, Albertini H, Mills NTW. Dental destruction in Broken-Hill man[J]. Journal of Human Evolution, 1980, 9(1): 33-39 |
[40] | Schmidt CW. On the relationship of dental microwear to dental macrowear[J]. American Journal of Physical Anthropology: The Official Publication of the American Association of Physical Anthropologists, 2010, 142(1): 67-73 |
[41] | Fox CL, Pérez-Pérez A. The diet of the Neanderthal Child Gibraltar 2 (Devil’s Tower) through the study of the vestibular striation pattern[J]. Journal of human Evolution, 1993, 24(1): 29-41 |
[42] |
Smith H. Patterns of molar wear in hunter-gatherers and agriculturalists[J]. Am J Phys Anthropol, 1984, 63: 39-56
pmid: 6422767 |
[43] | Puech PF, Pant R. Un modèle d’étude de l’alimentation des hommes fossiles[J]. Bulletins et Mémoires de la Société d’Anthropologie de Paris, 1980, 7(1): 61-64 |
[44] | 蒋洪恩. 吐鲁番洋海墓地植物遗存与古洋海人及环境之间的关系[D].硕士研究生论文, 北京: 中国科学院大学, 2006, 47-48 |
[45] | 杨凡. 中原地区仰韶文化中晚期的农业与社会[D].硕士研究生论文, 济南: 山东大学, 2021, 70-79 |
[46] | 尚童. 北魏民众的日常食物试探[D].硕士研究生论文, 长春: 吉林大学, 2019, 31-47+47-49 |
[47] | 王利华. 中古华北饮食文化的变迁[M]. 北京: 中国社会科学出版社, 2020, 197 |
[48] | 曹臣明. 平城附近鲜卑及北魏墓葬分布规律考[J]. 文物, 2016, 5: 61-69 |
[49] | 邬永祥. 饮食考古初论[D].硕士研究生论文, 合肥: 安徽大学, 2012, 8-14 |
[50] | 时子明. 河南自然条件与自然资源[M]. 郑州: 河南科学出版社, 1983, 22-49 |
[51] | 赵淑清. 大同城市历史地理研究[D].硕士研究生论文, 西安: 陕西师范大学, 2021, 19-29 |
[1] | 张全超, 孙语泽, 侯亮亮, 吉平, 朱永刚. 哈民忙哈遗址人和动物骨骼的C、N稳定同位素分析[J]. 人类学学报, 2022, 41(02): 261-273. |
[2] | 杨诗雨, 张群, 王龙, 张全超. 新疆吐鲁番胜金店墓地人骨的牙齿微磨耗[J]. 人类学学报, 2022, 41(02): 218-225. |
[3] | 张雅军, 仝涛, 李林辉, 赤列次仁. 西藏故如甲木墓地人群牙齿磨耗和食物结构的关系[J]. 人类学学报, 2019, 38(01): 107-118. |
[4] | 屈亚婷;胡珂;杨苗苗;崔建新. 新石器时代关中地区人类生业模式演变的生物考古学证据[J]. 人类学学报, 2018, 37(01): 96-109. |
[5] | 陈君;王頠;李大伟;廖卫. 广西田东中山遗址洞外岩厦出土动物骨骼的初步研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2017, 36(04): 527-536. |
[6] | 侯亮亮;古顺芳;张昕煜;戴玲玲;武夏;张国文;郭怡. 农业区游牧民族饮食文化的滞后性——基于大同东信广场北魏墓群人骨的稳定同位素研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2017, 36(03): 359-369. |
[7] | 张国文;陈凤山;孙祖栋;Richards MP. 早期鲜卑人和动物骨骼的稳定同位素分析[J]. 人类学学报, 2017, 36(01): 110-118. |
[8] | 张全超; Jacqueline T.ENG; 魏坚; 朱泓. 内蒙古察右前旗庙子沟遗址新石器时代人骨的稳定同位素分析[J]. 人类学学报, 2010, 29(03): 270-275. |
[9] | 裴德明;胡耀武;杨益民;张全超;张国文;田建文;王昌燧. 山西乡宁内阳垣遗址先民食物结构分析[J]. 人类学学报, 2008, 27(04): 379-384. |
[10] | 张雪莲. 应用古人骨的元素、同位素分析研究其食物结构[J]. 人类学学报, 2003, 22(01): 75-84. |
阅读次数 | ||||||
全文 |
|
|||||
摘要 |
|
|||||