人类学学报 ›› 2025, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (04): 631-641.doi: 10.16359/j.1000-3193/AAS.2025.0005cstr: 32091.14.j.1000-3193/AAS.2025.0005
收稿日期:2024-02-07
接受日期:2024-09-11
出版日期:2025-08-15
发布日期:2025-08-07
作者简介:胡荣,副教授,主要从事体质人类学与早期人类起源与演化研究。E-mail: hurong314@xmu.edu.cn
基金资助:Received:2024-02-07
Accepted:2024-09-11
Online:2025-08-15
Published:2025-08-07
摘要:
本研究在福建省福安市和福鼎市随机选取畲族年满18周岁的成人518人(其中男293人,女225人),并测量22项头面部指标,计算12个头面部指数。结果显示,福建畲族群体头型为中头型、高头型、狭头型,狭面型,中鼻型;除眼内角间宽和颧额宽指数外,其余头面部体质指标和指数均存在性别差异;头宽、面宽、眼内角宽、嘴唇相关指标(唇皮高、唇高、红唇厚度、口宽)、容貌耳长、头面高指数及口指数存在年龄差异。相比二十八年前的畲族,本文畲族群体头面部形态特征发生了明显的变化,分析其原因可是与城乡差异、环境和饮食变化及与汉族或其他民族通婚增多相关。对畲族和其他民族头面部数据进行主成分分析和聚类分析,发现福建畲族介于北方少数民族和汉族以及南方少数民族之间,其中与华南汉族群体、苗族、瑶族、水族、湖南瓦乡人更为接近,与云南、广西、贵州等地的其他南方少数民族以及北方少数民族族群差异较大。
中图分类号:
胡荣, 尹嘉昊. 福建畲族人群的头面部特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2025, 44(04): 631-641.
HU Rong, YIN Jiahao. Craniofacial characteristics of She people in Fujian[J]. Acta Anthropologica Sinica, 2025, 44(04): 631-641.
| 指标Index | 年龄组(岁)Age group(a) | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18s | 30s | 40s | 50s | 60s | 70~85 | 合计Total | |
| 头长Lg-op(mm) | 179.6±10.0 | 178.8±14.1 | 181.5±9.7 | 178.3±10.3 | 175.7±10.9 | 176.4±8.6 | 178.0±10.8 |
| 头宽Beu-eu(mm) | 148.2±9.5 | 145.1±12.6 | 142.2±10.1 | 142.0±7.0 | 141.5±10.8 | 140.8±7.3 | 142.6±9.8 |
| 额最小宽Bft-ft(mm) | 120.5±9.5 | 114.8±10.1 | 116.4±11.9 | 116.4±10.1 | 116.0±10.4 | 118.3±13.3 | 116.7±11.0 |
| 面宽Bzy-zy(mm) | 138.5±10.5 | 135.2±7.9 | 132.0±10.2 | 132.0±7.0 | 129.7±9.3 | 128.1±9.7 | 131.7±9.4 |
| 下颌角间宽Bgo-go(mm) | 109.5±20.7 | 106.7±12.6 | 106.0±8.5 | 106.0±11.0 | 104.5±7.7 | 100.3±8.1 | 105.1±10.9 |
| 眼内角间宽Ben-en(mm) | 31.8±5.8 | 30.7±4.0 | 28.7±5.3 | 27.7±4.9 | 24.3±5.5 | 23.9±5.9 | 27.1±5.9 |
| 眼外角间宽Bex-ex(mm) | 101.7±8.5 | 102.6±8.6 | 101.2±5.8 | 98.5±6.3 | 98.6±8.2 | 95.5±6.5 | 99.4±7.5 |
| 鼻宽Ba-a(mm) | 38.4±6.3 | 38.9±6.3 | 38.4±5.1 | 38.6±3.3 | 37.9±4.0 | 36.9±5.1 | 38.2±4.8 |
| 口宽Bch-ch(mm) | 48.0±4.8 | 50.2±5.4 | 49.7±4.1 | 49.0±5.5 | 49.8±4.7 | 50.0±5.6 | 49.6±5.0 |
| 容貌面高Htr-gn(mm) | 178.1±14.0 | 183.0±11.4 | 178.8±10.9 | 176.8±12.9 | 178.1±15.9 | 174.5±18.0 | 178.0±14.2 |
| 形态面高Hn-gn(mm) | 119.9±9.7 | 117.8±8.2 | 116.5±6.9 | 117.7±8.8 | 117.9±7.8 | 116.2±8.9 | 117.5±8.2 |
| 鼻高Hn-sn(mm) | 52.6±4.6 | 51.8±4.8 | 52.4±9.3 | 53.7±9.0 | 52.5±5.0 | 52.8±6.2 | 52.7±7.0 |
| 鼻长Ln(mm) | 44.6±5.4 | 46.1±6.6 | 44.1± 5.2 | 44.9± 5.9 | 43.7± 5.4 | 44.1± 6.0 | 44.5± 5.7 |
| 鼻深Dsn-prn(mm) | 17.5± 3.2 | 18.5± 8.7 | 16.2± 2.9 | 17.5± 3.7 | 16.8± 3.5 | 17.4±4.9 | 17.2±4.6 |
| 上唇皮肤部高Hsn-ls(mm) | 15.0±2.8 | 15.9±3.1 | 16.1±3.8 | 16.3±3.1 | 17.4±3.1 | 17.1±4.2 | 16.5±3.4 |
| 唇高Hls-li(mm) | 20.3±3.4 | 18.0±3.5 | 17.1±3.4 | 16.1±3.5 | 15.8±3.8 | 13.7±4.2 | 16.4±4.0 |
| 红唇厚度Hls-sto(mm) | 9.8±1.9 | 8.2±2.1 | 8.2±2.1 | 7.5±2.1 | 7.5±2.2 | 5.9±2.1 | 7.7±2.3 |
| 容貌耳长Lsa-sba(mm) | 58.6±6.4 | 63.6±4.6 | 63.4±5.2 | 64.5±6.5 | 62.4±8.2 | 65.5±9.2 | 63.3±7.2 |
| 容貌耳宽Bpro-pa(mm) | 31.1±4.2 | 32.1±4.3 | 32.5±5.9 | 32.0±3.4 | 30.4±4.7 | 31.9±5.9 | 31.6±4.8 |
| 耳上头高Hve-tr(mm) | 136.3±25.9 | 141.4±13.6 | 141.5±14.5 | 134.1±17.3 | 141.6±14.6 | 137.8±14.6 | 139.0±16.3 |
| 头围Che (mm) | 564.9±24.4 | 559.7±16.0 | 562.1±18.1 | 561.7±17.2 | 553.4±16.9 | 555.3±15.7 | 558.6±17.9 |
| 面颊褶dfa (mm) | 16.4±4.9 | 14.3±4.7 | 14.6±4.9 | 13±4.8 | 13.4±5.0 | 12.9±4.5 | 13.8±4.9 |
| 头长宽指数Ib/L | 82.6±4.5 | 81.3±5.6 | 78.5±5.5 | 79.9±6.4 | 80.7±5.8 | 79.9±4.8 | 80.2±5.7 |
| 头长高指数Ih/L | 76.2±15.5 | 79.5±9.3 | 78.2±9.4 | 75.6±11.2 | 81.0±10.4 | 78.4±9.9 | 78.4±10.8 |
| 头宽高指数Ih/b | 92.3±18.5 | 97.9±11.1 | 99.9±11.3 | 94.6±12.3 | 100.5±12.3 | 98.3±12.3 | 97.9±12.7 |
| 形态面指数Imf | 86.7±5.3 | 87.4±6.8 | 88.6±7.8 | 89.4±8.2 | 91.3±8.1 | 91.1±8.7 | 89.6±7.9 |
| 容貌面指数Ipf | 128.8±8.0 | 135.7±10.0 | 136±10.6 | 134.1±10.5 | 137.9±14.3 | 136.6±14.5 | 135.6±12.2 |
| 头面高指数Ih,fa | 92.6±28.1 | 83.9±8.7 | 83.1±9.2 | 89.4±15.4 | 84.1±10.4 | 85±9.9 | 85.8±13.5 |
| 头面宽指数Ib,fa | 93.5±5.6 | 93.7±7.9 | 93.2±8.6 | 93.1±5.3 | 91.9±7.2 | 91.1±6.2 | 92.6±7.0 |
| 颧额宽指数Ib,fr | 87.4±8.8 | 85.1±8.5 | 88.6±10.1 | 88.4±8.7 | 89.8±8.9 | 92.8±12.5 | 88.9±9.8 |
| 额顶宽指数Ib,T | 81.5±7.9 | 79.4±7.2 | 82.2±9.3 | 82.1±6.9 | 82.2±7.6 | 84±8.3 | 82.0±7.9 |
| 容貌耳指数Iear | 53.4±7.5 | 50.5±6.7 | 51.4±9.7 | 49.9±6.9 | 49.1±7.4 | 49.1±8.4 | 50.2±7.8 |
| 鼻指数Inos | 73.0±9.8 | 75.7±13.3 | 74.8±13.4 | 73.3±10.6 | 72.6±8.7 | 70.9±13.3 | 73.3±11.4 |
| 口指数Iora | 42.6±7.9 | 36.2±7.2 | 34.7±7.5 | 33.4±9.0 | 31.9±8.0 | 27.8±9.4 | 33.5±8.9 |
| 注:长宽厚高单位为 mm。 The unit of heighth, breath, thickness and length is mm. | |||||||
表1 各年龄段畲族男性的头面部指标($\bar{x}±s$)
Tab.1 Means and indices of craniofacial characteristics of males of the She ethnic group across different age groups
| 指标Index | 年龄组(岁)Age group(a) | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18s | 30s | 40s | 50s | 60s | 70~85 | 合计Total | |
| 头长Lg-op(mm) | 179.6±10.0 | 178.8±14.1 | 181.5±9.7 | 178.3±10.3 | 175.7±10.9 | 176.4±8.6 | 178.0±10.8 |
| 头宽Beu-eu(mm) | 148.2±9.5 | 145.1±12.6 | 142.2±10.1 | 142.0±7.0 | 141.5±10.8 | 140.8±7.3 | 142.6±9.8 |
| 额最小宽Bft-ft(mm) | 120.5±9.5 | 114.8±10.1 | 116.4±11.9 | 116.4±10.1 | 116.0±10.4 | 118.3±13.3 | 116.7±11.0 |
| 面宽Bzy-zy(mm) | 138.5±10.5 | 135.2±7.9 | 132.0±10.2 | 132.0±7.0 | 129.7±9.3 | 128.1±9.7 | 131.7±9.4 |
| 下颌角间宽Bgo-go(mm) | 109.5±20.7 | 106.7±12.6 | 106.0±8.5 | 106.0±11.0 | 104.5±7.7 | 100.3±8.1 | 105.1±10.9 |
| 眼内角间宽Ben-en(mm) | 31.8±5.8 | 30.7±4.0 | 28.7±5.3 | 27.7±4.9 | 24.3±5.5 | 23.9±5.9 | 27.1±5.9 |
| 眼外角间宽Bex-ex(mm) | 101.7±8.5 | 102.6±8.6 | 101.2±5.8 | 98.5±6.3 | 98.6±8.2 | 95.5±6.5 | 99.4±7.5 |
| 鼻宽Ba-a(mm) | 38.4±6.3 | 38.9±6.3 | 38.4±5.1 | 38.6±3.3 | 37.9±4.0 | 36.9±5.1 | 38.2±4.8 |
| 口宽Bch-ch(mm) | 48.0±4.8 | 50.2±5.4 | 49.7±4.1 | 49.0±5.5 | 49.8±4.7 | 50.0±5.6 | 49.6±5.0 |
| 容貌面高Htr-gn(mm) | 178.1±14.0 | 183.0±11.4 | 178.8±10.9 | 176.8±12.9 | 178.1±15.9 | 174.5±18.0 | 178.0±14.2 |
| 形态面高Hn-gn(mm) | 119.9±9.7 | 117.8±8.2 | 116.5±6.9 | 117.7±8.8 | 117.9±7.8 | 116.2±8.9 | 117.5±8.2 |
| 鼻高Hn-sn(mm) | 52.6±4.6 | 51.8±4.8 | 52.4±9.3 | 53.7±9.0 | 52.5±5.0 | 52.8±6.2 | 52.7±7.0 |
| 鼻长Ln(mm) | 44.6±5.4 | 46.1±6.6 | 44.1± 5.2 | 44.9± 5.9 | 43.7± 5.4 | 44.1± 6.0 | 44.5± 5.7 |
| 鼻深Dsn-prn(mm) | 17.5± 3.2 | 18.5± 8.7 | 16.2± 2.9 | 17.5± 3.7 | 16.8± 3.5 | 17.4±4.9 | 17.2±4.6 |
| 上唇皮肤部高Hsn-ls(mm) | 15.0±2.8 | 15.9±3.1 | 16.1±3.8 | 16.3±3.1 | 17.4±3.1 | 17.1±4.2 | 16.5±3.4 |
| 唇高Hls-li(mm) | 20.3±3.4 | 18.0±3.5 | 17.1±3.4 | 16.1±3.5 | 15.8±3.8 | 13.7±4.2 | 16.4±4.0 |
| 红唇厚度Hls-sto(mm) | 9.8±1.9 | 8.2±2.1 | 8.2±2.1 | 7.5±2.1 | 7.5±2.2 | 5.9±2.1 | 7.7±2.3 |
| 容貌耳长Lsa-sba(mm) | 58.6±6.4 | 63.6±4.6 | 63.4±5.2 | 64.5±6.5 | 62.4±8.2 | 65.5±9.2 | 63.3±7.2 |
| 容貌耳宽Bpro-pa(mm) | 31.1±4.2 | 32.1±4.3 | 32.5±5.9 | 32.0±3.4 | 30.4±4.7 | 31.9±5.9 | 31.6±4.8 |
| 耳上头高Hve-tr(mm) | 136.3±25.9 | 141.4±13.6 | 141.5±14.5 | 134.1±17.3 | 141.6±14.6 | 137.8±14.6 | 139.0±16.3 |
| 头围Che (mm) | 564.9±24.4 | 559.7±16.0 | 562.1±18.1 | 561.7±17.2 | 553.4±16.9 | 555.3±15.7 | 558.6±17.9 |
| 面颊褶dfa (mm) | 16.4±4.9 | 14.3±4.7 | 14.6±4.9 | 13±4.8 | 13.4±5.0 | 12.9±4.5 | 13.8±4.9 |
| 头长宽指数Ib/L | 82.6±4.5 | 81.3±5.6 | 78.5±5.5 | 79.9±6.4 | 80.7±5.8 | 79.9±4.8 | 80.2±5.7 |
| 头长高指数Ih/L | 76.2±15.5 | 79.5±9.3 | 78.2±9.4 | 75.6±11.2 | 81.0±10.4 | 78.4±9.9 | 78.4±10.8 |
| 头宽高指数Ih/b | 92.3±18.5 | 97.9±11.1 | 99.9±11.3 | 94.6±12.3 | 100.5±12.3 | 98.3±12.3 | 97.9±12.7 |
| 形态面指数Imf | 86.7±5.3 | 87.4±6.8 | 88.6±7.8 | 89.4±8.2 | 91.3±8.1 | 91.1±8.7 | 89.6±7.9 |
| 容貌面指数Ipf | 128.8±8.0 | 135.7±10.0 | 136±10.6 | 134.1±10.5 | 137.9±14.3 | 136.6±14.5 | 135.6±12.2 |
| 头面高指数Ih,fa | 92.6±28.1 | 83.9±8.7 | 83.1±9.2 | 89.4±15.4 | 84.1±10.4 | 85±9.9 | 85.8±13.5 |
| 头面宽指数Ib,fa | 93.5±5.6 | 93.7±7.9 | 93.2±8.6 | 93.1±5.3 | 91.9±7.2 | 91.1±6.2 | 92.6±7.0 |
| 颧额宽指数Ib,fr | 87.4±8.8 | 85.1±8.5 | 88.6±10.1 | 88.4±8.7 | 89.8±8.9 | 92.8±12.5 | 88.9±9.8 |
| 额顶宽指数Ib,T | 81.5±7.9 | 79.4±7.2 | 82.2±9.3 | 82.1±6.9 | 82.2±7.6 | 84±8.3 | 82.0±7.9 |
| 容貌耳指数Iear | 53.4±7.5 | 50.5±6.7 | 51.4±9.7 | 49.9±6.9 | 49.1±7.4 | 49.1±8.4 | 50.2±7.8 |
| 鼻指数Inos | 73.0±9.8 | 75.7±13.3 | 74.8±13.4 | 73.3±10.6 | 72.6±8.7 | 70.9±13.3 | 73.3±11.4 |
| 口指数Iora | 42.6±7.9 | 36.2±7.2 | 34.7±7.5 | 33.4±9.0 | 31.9±8.0 | 27.8±9.4 | 33.5±8.9 |
| 注:长宽厚高单位为 mm。 The unit of heighth, breath, thickness and length is mm. | |||||||
| 指标Index | 年龄组(岁)Age group(a) | u | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18s | 30s | 40s | 50s | 60s | 70~85 | 合计Total | ||
| 头长Lg-op(mm) | 170.2±13.7 | 168.9±10.7 | 172.6±10.8 | 169.1±9.1 | 170.0±8.9 | 174.8±11.3 | 170.8±10.4 | 7.68** |
| 头宽Beu-eu(mm) | 141.2±8.9 | 134.3±9.9 | 139.6±10.3 | 135.7±6.6 | 136.0±8.4 | 140.1±13.4 | 137.4±9.5 | 6.09** |
| 额最小宽Bft-ft(mm) | 117.2±9.2 | 109.9±13.3 | 115.5±13.2 | 115.2±15.0 | 112.8±12.6 | 111.7±6.4 | 113.9±12.7 | 2.63** |
| 面宽Bzy-zy(mm) | 128.4±9.0 | 125.3±8.7 | 127.8±8.8 | 126.9±11.5 | 123.0±6.2 | 121.9±10.6 | 125.5±9.4 | 7.44** |
| 下颌角间宽Bgo-go(mm) | 97.0±9.7 | 97.6±6.4 | 101.1±7.7 | 99.7±9.9 | 99.6±11.4 | 95.5±7.8 | 99.0±9.4 | 6.83** |
| 眼内角间宽Ben-en(mm) | 30.4±3.4 | 27.9±4.5 | 27.6±3.8 | 25.7±5.0 | 24.6±4.7 | 24.4±6.1 | 26.3±5.0 | 1.67 |
| 眼外角间宽Bex-ex(mm) | 98.3±7.0 | 97.3±4.9 | 98.6±6.7 | 96.4±6.2 | 96.2±7.8 | 93.9±8.2 | 96.8±7.0 | 4.07** |
| 鼻宽Ba-a(mm) | 35.6±2.6 | 36.4±3.1 | 36.1±3.4 | 36.1±3.5 | 35.3±4.7 | 37.2±4.0 | 36.0±3.8 | 5.82** |
| 口宽Bch-ch(mm) | 43.4±4.1 | 47.1±4.0 | 47.5±4.2 | 47.9±5.3 | 46.6±5.0 | 47.5±7.6 | 47.0±5.2 | 5.74** |
| 容貌面高Htr-gn(mm) | 168.5±13.9 | 174.2±11.7 | 172.8±11.5 | 168.8±10.8 | 168.7±12.3 | 171.3±14.2 | 170.4±12.1 | 6.57** |
| 形态面高Hn-gn(mm) | 108.7±6.6 | 112.2±9.0 | 111.9±9.2 | 109.6±6.7 | 109.5±7.7 | 110.5±10.2 | 110.3±8.2 | 9.91** |
| 鼻高Hn-sn(mm) | 51.9±7.0 | 47.8±6.6 | 49.8±5.3 | 49.1±5.1 | 49.9±6.5 | 51.7±5.5 | 49.9±5.9 | 4.93** |
| 鼻长Ln(mm) | 43.0± 5.1 | 41.5± 6.0 | 42.7± 7.0 | 40.9±4.7 | 41.1±4.6 | 42.4± 4.7 | 41.7± 5.0 | 5.94** |
| 鼻深Dsn-prn(mm) | 14.2± 3.0 | 13.8± 3.9 | 14.9± 3.0 | 14.4±3.5 | 15.4± 5.8 | 14.0± 3.8 | 14.6± 4.1 | 6.78** |
| 上唇皮肤部高Hsn-ls(mm) | 12.7±2.6 | 14.2±3.2 | 14.8±3.0 | 15.1±3.2 | 16.5±3.5 | 15.4±4.2 | 15.1±3.5 | 4.57** |
| 唇高Hls-li(mm) | 17.5±3.5 | 18.1±3.7 | 17.1±4.0 | 16.2±3.3 | 13.5±3.4 | 12.8±3.2 | 15.7±4.0 | 1.97* |
| 红唇厚度Hls-sto(mm) | 8.8±2.1 | 8.2±1.4 | 8.2±2.4 | 7.3±1.9 | 6.2±1.7 | 6.0±2.0 | 7.3±2.1 | 2.06* |
| 容貌耳长Lsa-sba(mm) | 57.1±6.0 | 57.8±5.7 | 58.7±5.2 | 58.9±6.1 | 60.8±6.0 | 63.4±8.0 | 59.6±6.3 | 6.22** |
| 容貌耳宽Bpro-pa(mm) | 29.5±3.3 | 29.7±2.9 | 30.0±3.9 | 30.3±4.2 | 30.5±5.1 | 32.6±6.2 | 30.4±4.5 | 2.92** |
| 耳上头高Hve-tr(mm) | 138.7±11.3 | 131.8±12.8 | 133.8±13.9 | 127.9±13.4 | 130.4±12.6 | 139.8±20.9 | 132.4±14.6 | 4.85** |
| 头围Che (mm) | 547.2±15.4 | 549.5±20.4 | 549.4±21.4 | 543.9±23.1 | 544.4±17.7 | 543.3±16.6 | 546.0±19.9 | 7.46** |
| 面颊褶dfa (mm) | 18.6±6.2 | 16.2±4.8 | 17.9±5.6 | 17.8±4.5 | 17.6±4 | 16.0±4.7 | 17.5±4.9 | 8.52** |
| 头长宽指数Ib/L | 83.1±3.6 | 79.6±5.9 | 80.9±4.44 | 80.5±6.3 | 80.2±5.7 | 80.1±5.8 | 80.6±5.5 | 0.81 |
| 头长高指数Ih/L | 81.8±7.8 | 78.6±10.8 | 77.7±8.0 | 75.9±9.5 | 76.9±8.5 | 80.3±13.8 | 77.8±9.7 | 0.66 |
| 头宽高指数Ih/b | 98.5±9.4 | 98.7±11.1 | 96.2±11.1 | 94.6±11.2 | 96.3±11.3 | 100.8±18.7 | 96.8±12.2 | 1.00 |
| 形态面指数Imf | 85.0±7.0 | 90.1±10.5 | 88.0±10.0 | 87.0±8.6 | 89.2±7.5 | 91.0±8.7 | 88.3±8.8 | 1.74 |
| 容貌面指数Ipf | 131.4±9.4 | 139.5±11.2 | 135.6±10.1 | 133.8±11.1 | 137.3±10.7 | 141.2±12.7 | 136.3±11.1 | 0.68 |
| 头面高指数Ih,fa | 78.7±6.7 | 85.9±10.7 | 84.5±11 | 86.7±11.9 | 84.7±10.2 | 80.3±11 | 84.3±10.9 | 1.40 |
| 头面宽指数Ib,fa | 91.1±6.3 | 93.5±4.6 | 91.9±8.1 | 93.6±8.2 | 90.7±6.4 | 87.6±9.9 | 91.6±7.7 | 1.52 |
| 颧额宽指数Ib,fr | 91.7±9.2 | 87.8±9.3 | 90.8±11.8 | 91.7±16.8 | 92±11.8 | 92.2±8.4 | 91.2±12.5 | 2.27* |
| 额顶宽指数Ib,T | 83.2±7.4 | 81.9±7.6 | 83.2±11.7 | 85.1±11.5 | 83.4±12.0 | 80.4±8.4 | 83.2±10.7 | 1.41 |
| 容貌耳指数Iear | 51.9±5.6 | 51.7±5.5 | 51.1±5.6 | 51.9±8.2 | 50.4±8.3 | 51.8±9.4 | 51.4±7.4 | 1.79 |
| 鼻指数Inos | 69.4±8.8 | 77.4±11.5 | 73.0±8.9 | 74.4±10.4 | 71.7±12.1 | 73.0±12.7 | 73.2±10.9 | 0.10 |
| 口指数Iora | 40.5±8.9 | 38.8±8.4 | 36.2±8.3 | 34.0±8.2 | 29.3±8.6 | 27.2±5.8 | 33.6±9.1 | 0.13 |
表2 各年龄段畲族女性的头面部指标($\bar{x}±s$)
Tab.2 Means and indices of craniofacial characteristics of females of the She ethnic group across different age groups
| 指标Index | 年龄组(岁)Age group(a) | u | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18s | 30s | 40s | 50s | 60s | 70~85 | 合计Total | ||
| 头长Lg-op(mm) | 170.2±13.7 | 168.9±10.7 | 172.6±10.8 | 169.1±9.1 | 170.0±8.9 | 174.8±11.3 | 170.8±10.4 | 7.68** |
| 头宽Beu-eu(mm) | 141.2±8.9 | 134.3±9.9 | 139.6±10.3 | 135.7±6.6 | 136.0±8.4 | 140.1±13.4 | 137.4±9.5 | 6.09** |
| 额最小宽Bft-ft(mm) | 117.2±9.2 | 109.9±13.3 | 115.5±13.2 | 115.2±15.0 | 112.8±12.6 | 111.7±6.4 | 113.9±12.7 | 2.63** |
| 面宽Bzy-zy(mm) | 128.4±9.0 | 125.3±8.7 | 127.8±8.8 | 126.9±11.5 | 123.0±6.2 | 121.9±10.6 | 125.5±9.4 | 7.44** |
| 下颌角间宽Bgo-go(mm) | 97.0±9.7 | 97.6±6.4 | 101.1±7.7 | 99.7±9.9 | 99.6±11.4 | 95.5±7.8 | 99.0±9.4 | 6.83** |
| 眼内角间宽Ben-en(mm) | 30.4±3.4 | 27.9±4.5 | 27.6±3.8 | 25.7±5.0 | 24.6±4.7 | 24.4±6.1 | 26.3±5.0 | 1.67 |
| 眼外角间宽Bex-ex(mm) | 98.3±7.0 | 97.3±4.9 | 98.6±6.7 | 96.4±6.2 | 96.2±7.8 | 93.9±8.2 | 96.8±7.0 | 4.07** |
| 鼻宽Ba-a(mm) | 35.6±2.6 | 36.4±3.1 | 36.1±3.4 | 36.1±3.5 | 35.3±4.7 | 37.2±4.0 | 36.0±3.8 | 5.82** |
| 口宽Bch-ch(mm) | 43.4±4.1 | 47.1±4.0 | 47.5±4.2 | 47.9±5.3 | 46.6±5.0 | 47.5±7.6 | 47.0±5.2 | 5.74** |
| 容貌面高Htr-gn(mm) | 168.5±13.9 | 174.2±11.7 | 172.8±11.5 | 168.8±10.8 | 168.7±12.3 | 171.3±14.2 | 170.4±12.1 | 6.57** |
| 形态面高Hn-gn(mm) | 108.7±6.6 | 112.2±9.0 | 111.9±9.2 | 109.6±6.7 | 109.5±7.7 | 110.5±10.2 | 110.3±8.2 | 9.91** |
| 鼻高Hn-sn(mm) | 51.9±7.0 | 47.8±6.6 | 49.8±5.3 | 49.1±5.1 | 49.9±6.5 | 51.7±5.5 | 49.9±5.9 | 4.93** |
| 鼻长Ln(mm) | 43.0± 5.1 | 41.5± 6.0 | 42.7± 7.0 | 40.9±4.7 | 41.1±4.6 | 42.4± 4.7 | 41.7± 5.0 | 5.94** |
| 鼻深Dsn-prn(mm) | 14.2± 3.0 | 13.8± 3.9 | 14.9± 3.0 | 14.4±3.5 | 15.4± 5.8 | 14.0± 3.8 | 14.6± 4.1 | 6.78** |
| 上唇皮肤部高Hsn-ls(mm) | 12.7±2.6 | 14.2±3.2 | 14.8±3.0 | 15.1±3.2 | 16.5±3.5 | 15.4±4.2 | 15.1±3.5 | 4.57** |
| 唇高Hls-li(mm) | 17.5±3.5 | 18.1±3.7 | 17.1±4.0 | 16.2±3.3 | 13.5±3.4 | 12.8±3.2 | 15.7±4.0 | 1.97* |
| 红唇厚度Hls-sto(mm) | 8.8±2.1 | 8.2±1.4 | 8.2±2.4 | 7.3±1.9 | 6.2±1.7 | 6.0±2.0 | 7.3±2.1 | 2.06* |
| 容貌耳长Lsa-sba(mm) | 57.1±6.0 | 57.8±5.7 | 58.7±5.2 | 58.9±6.1 | 60.8±6.0 | 63.4±8.0 | 59.6±6.3 | 6.22** |
| 容貌耳宽Bpro-pa(mm) | 29.5±3.3 | 29.7±2.9 | 30.0±3.9 | 30.3±4.2 | 30.5±5.1 | 32.6±6.2 | 30.4±4.5 | 2.92** |
| 耳上头高Hve-tr(mm) | 138.7±11.3 | 131.8±12.8 | 133.8±13.9 | 127.9±13.4 | 130.4±12.6 | 139.8±20.9 | 132.4±14.6 | 4.85** |
| 头围Che (mm) | 547.2±15.4 | 549.5±20.4 | 549.4±21.4 | 543.9±23.1 | 544.4±17.7 | 543.3±16.6 | 546.0±19.9 | 7.46** |
| 面颊褶dfa (mm) | 18.6±6.2 | 16.2±4.8 | 17.9±5.6 | 17.8±4.5 | 17.6±4 | 16.0±4.7 | 17.5±4.9 | 8.52** |
| 头长宽指数Ib/L | 83.1±3.6 | 79.6±5.9 | 80.9±4.44 | 80.5±6.3 | 80.2±5.7 | 80.1±5.8 | 80.6±5.5 | 0.81 |
| 头长高指数Ih/L | 81.8±7.8 | 78.6±10.8 | 77.7±8.0 | 75.9±9.5 | 76.9±8.5 | 80.3±13.8 | 77.8±9.7 | 0.66 |
| 头宽高指数Ih/b | 98.5±9.4 | 98.7±11.1 | 96.2±11.1 | 94.6±11.2 | 96.3±11.3 | 100.8±18.7 | 96.8±12.2 | 1.00 |
| 形态面指数Imf | 85.0±7.0 | 90.1±10.5 | 88.0±10.0 | 87.0±8.6 | 89.2±7.5 | 91.0±8.7 | 88.3±8.8 | 1.74 |
| 容貌面指数Ipf | 131.4±9.4 | 139.5±11.2 | 135.6±10.1 | 133.8±11.1 | 137.3±10.7 | 141.2±12.7 | 136.3±11.1 | 0.68 |
| 头面高指数Ih,fa | 78.7±6.7 | 85.9±10.7 | 84.5±11 | 86.7±11.9 | 84.7±10.2 | 80.3±11 | 84.3±10.9 | 1.40 |
| 头面宽指数Ib,fa | 91.1±6.3 | 93.5±4.6 | 91.9±8.1 | 93.6±8.2 | 90.7±6.4 | 87.6±9.9 | 91.6±7.7 | 1.52 |
| 颧额宽指数Ib,fr | 91.7±9.2 | 87.8±9.3 | 90.8±11.8 | 91.7±16.8 | 92±11.8 | 92.2±8.4 | 91.2±12.5 | 2.27* |
| 额顶宽指数Ib,T | 83.2±7.4 | 81.9±7.6 | 83.2±11.7 | 85.1±11.5 | 83.4±12.0 | 80.4±8.4 | 83.2±10.7 | 1.41 |
| 容貌耳指数Iear | 51.9±5.6 | 51.7±5.5 | 51.1±5.6 | 51.9±8.2 | 50.4±8.3 | 51.8±9.4 | 51.4±7.4 | 1.79 |
| 鼻指数Inos | 69.4±8.8 | 77.4±11.5 | 73.0±8.9 | 74.4±10.4 | 71.7±12.1 | 73.0±12.7 | 73.2±10.9 | 0.10 |
| 口指数Iora | 40.5±8.9 | 38.8±8.4 | 36.2±8.3 | 34.0±8.2 | 29.3±8.6 | 27.2±5.8 | 33.6±9.1 | 0.13 |
| 指标Index | 男性Male (n=293) | 女性Female(n=225) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F | p | F | p | ||
| 头长Lg-op(mm) | 2.177 | 0.057 | 1.618 | 0.156 | |
| 头宽Beu-eu(mm) | 2.513 | 0.030 | 2.773 | 0.019 | |
| 额最小宽Bft-ft(mm) | 0.991 | 0.423 | 1.230 | 0.296 | |
| 面宽Bzy-zy(mm) | 5.654 | 0.000 | 2.749 | 0.020 | |
| 下颌角间宽Bgo-go(mm) | 2.695 | 0.021 | 1.610 | 0.159 | |
| 眼内角间宽Ben-en(mm) | 15.648 | 0.000 | 6.675 | 0.000 | |
| 眼外角间宽Bex-ex(mm) | 5.154 | 0.000 | 1.814 | 0.111 | |
| 鼻宽Ba-a(mm) | .937 | 0.458 | 1.011 | 0.412 | |
| 口宽Bch-ch(mm) | .767 | 0.574 | 2.479 | 0.033 | |
| 容貌面高Htr-gn(mm) | 1.510 | 0.186 | 1.363 | 0.239 | |
| 形态面高Hn-gn(mm) | .798 | 0.552 | 0.996 | 0.421 | |
| 鼻高Hn-sn(mm) | .393 | 0.854 | 1.803 | 0.113 | |
| 鼻长Ln(mm) | .971 | 0.436 | 0.425 | 0.831 | |
| 鼻深Dsn-prn(mm) | 1.334 | 0.250 | 0.858 | 0.510 | |
| 上唇皮肤部高Hsn-ls(mm) | 2.779 | 0.018 | 4.382 | 0.001 | |
| 唇高Hls-li(mm) | 11.897 | 0.000 | 12.478 | 0.000 | |
| 红唇厚度Hls-sto(mm) | 11.167 | 0.000 | 11.066 | 0.000 | |
| 容貌耳长Lsa-sba(mm) | 3.335 | 0.006 | 3.772 | 0.003 | |
| 容貌耳宽Bpro-pa(mm) | 1.495 | 0.191 | 1.648 | 0.148 | |
| 头围Che (mm) | 3.061 | 0.010 | 0.724 | 0.606 | |
| 面颊褶dfa (mm) | 2.413 | 0.036 | 1.145 | 0.338 | |
| 头长宽指数Ib/L | 2.241 | 0.050 | 1.095 | 0.364 | |
| 头长高指数Ih/L | 2.086 | 0.067 | 1.564 | 0.171 | |
| 头宽高指数Ih/b | 2.727 | 0.020 | 1.168 | 0.326 | |
| 形态面指数Imf | 2.420 | 0.036 | 1.628 | 0.154 | |
| 容貌面指数Ipf | 2.197 | 0.055 | 2.964 | 0.013 | |
| 头面高指数Ih,fa | 2.936 | 0.013 | 2.425 | 0.036 | |
| 头面宽指数Ib,fa | 0.914 | 0.472 | 2.696 | 0.022 | |
| 颧额宽指数Ib,fr | 2.739 | 0.020 | 0.460 | 0.806 | |
| 额顶宽指数Ib,T | 1.383 | 0.231 | 0.785 | 0.562 | |
| 容貌耳指数Iear | 1.482 | 0.196 | 0.284 | 0.922 | |
| 鼻指数Inos | 0.903 | 0.479 | 1.557 | 0.173 | |
| 口指数Iora | 10.792 | 0.000 | 11.700 | 0.000 | |
表3 畲族头面部指标年龄差异的单因素ANOVA检验
Tab.3 One-way ANOVA test on age differences in craniofacial characteristics of the She ethnic group
| 指标Index | 男性Male (n=293) | 女性Female(n=225) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F | p | F | p | ||
| 头长Lg-op(mm) | 2.177 | 0.057 | 1.618 | 0.156 | |
| 头宽Beu-eu(mm) | 2.513 | 0.030 | 2.773 | 0.019 | |
| 额最小宽Bft-ft(mm) | 0.991 | 0.423 | 1.230 | 0.296 | |
| 面宽Bzy-zy(mm) | 5.654 | 0.000 | 2.749 | 0.020 | |
| 下颌角间宽Bgo-go(mm) | 2.695 | 0.021 | 1.610 | 0.159 | |
| 眼内角间宽Ben-en(mm) | 15.648 | 0.000 | 6.675 | 0.000 | |
| 眼外角间宽Bex-ex(mm) | 5.154 | 0.000 | 1.814 | 0.111 | |
| 鼻宽Ba-a(mm) | .937 | 0.458 | 1.011 | 0.412 | |
| 口宽Bch-ch(mm) | .767 | 0.574 | 2.479 | 0.033 | |
| 容貌面高Htr-gn(mm) | 1.510 | 0.186 | 1.363 | 0.239 | |
| 形态面高Hn-gn(mm) | .798 | 0.552 | 0.996 | 0.421 | |
| 鼻高Hn-sn(mm) | .393 | 0.854 | 1.803 | 0.113 | |
| 鼻长Ln(mm) | .971 | 0.436 | 0.425 | 0.831 | |
| 鼻深Dsn-prn(mm) | 1.334 | 0.250 | 0.858 | 0.510 | |
| 上唇皮肤部高Hsn-ls(mm) | 2.779 | 0.018 | 4.382 | 0.001 | |
| 唇高Hls-li(mm) | 11.897 | 0.000 | 12.478 | 0.000 | |
| 红唇厚度Hls-sto(mm) | 11.167 | 0.000 | 11.066 | 0.000 | |
| 容貌耳长Lsa-sba(mm) | 3.335 | 0.006 | 3.772 | 0.003 | |
| 容貌耳宽Bpro-pa(mm) | 1.495 | 0.191 | 1.648 | 0.148 | |
| 头围Che (mm) | 3.061 | 0.010 | 0.724 | 0.606 | |
| 面颊褶dfa (mm) | 2.413 | 0.036 | 1.145 | 0.338 | |
| 头长宽指数Ib/L | 2.241 | 0.050 | 1.095 | 0.364 | |
| 头长高指数Ih/L | 2.086 | 0.067 | 1.564 | 0.171 | |
| 头宽高指数Ih/b | 2.727 | 0.020 | 1.168 | 0.326 | |
| 形态面指数Imf | 2.420 | 0.036 | 1.628 | 0.154 | |
| 容貌面指数Ipf | 2.197 | 0.055 | 2.964 | 0.013 | |
| 头面高指数Ih,fa | 2.936 | 0.013 | 2.425 | 0.036 | |
| 头面宽指数Ib,fa | 0.914 | 0.472 | 2.696 | 0.022 | |
| 颧额宽指数Ib,fr | 2.739 | 0.020 | 0.460 | 0.806 | |
| 额顶宽指数Ib,T | 1.383 | 0.231 | 0.785 | 0.562 | |
| 容貌耳指数Iear | 1.482 | 0.196 | 0.284 | 0.922 | |
| 鼻指数Inos | 0.903 | 0.479 | 1.557 | 0.173 | |
| 口指数Iora | 10.792 | 0.000 | 11.700 | 0.000 | |
| 指标Index | 男性Male | 女性Female | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| n(2018)=85 | n(1996)=212 | t | n(2018)=61 | n(1996)=200 | t | ||
| 头长Lg-op(mm) | 181.0±12.2 | 187.2±6.0 | -4.46*** | 171.1±11.2 | 177.9±9.1 | -4.34*** | |
| 头宽Beu-eu(mm) | 145.2±11.8 | 146.4±6.3 | -0.86 | 137.5±10.7 | 140.0±5.7 | -1.74 | |
| 额最小宽Bft-ft(mm) | 116.0±10.7 | 105.1±5.9 | 8.83*** | 114.1±14.9 | 102.1±5.1 | 6.19*** | |
| 面宽Bzy-zy(mm) | 135.4±9.6 | 138.0±5.9 | -2.36* | 127.2±8.8 | 131.3±5.0 | -3.47*** | |
| 眼内角间宽Ben-en(mm) | 30.9±4.7 | 34.4±3.5 | -6.20*** | 28.0±4.3 | 32.8±3.2 | -8.21*** | |
| 眼外角间宽Bex-ex(mm) | 102.2±6.5 | 89.4±4.5 | 16.56*** | 98.4±6.7 | 85.7±4.4 | 13.96*** | |
| 鼻宽Ba-a(mm) | 38.7±5.4 | 37.8±2.9 | 1.42 | 36.4±3.0 | 34.8±5.2 | 3.02** | |
| 口宽Bch-ch(mm) | 50.0±4.7 | 52.2±4.3 | -3.70*** | 47.0±3.9 | 49.1±4.9 | -3.50*** | |
| 容貌面高Htr-gn(mm) | 181.6±11.3 | 188.9±8.9 | -5.34*** | 172.2±12.3 | 178.9±14.2 | -3.58*** | |
| 形态面高Hn-gn(mm) | 117.8±8.1 | 124.8±6.9 | -6.97*** | 111.9±8.9 | 118.0±6.5 | -4.96*** | |
| 鼻高Hn-sn(mm) | 52.4±6.0 | 55.5±3.8 | -4.40*** | 49.4±6.4 | 52.7±4.2 | -3.80*** | |
| 唇高Hls-li(mm) | 18.1±3.4 | 19.5±3.1 | -3.22** | 17.8±3.8 | 18.5±3.0 | -1.35 | |
| 容貌耳长Lsa-sba(mm) | 62.7±5.1 | 63.2±4.1 | -0.77 | 57.9±5.3 | 59.1±3.8 | -1.60 | |
| 容貌耳宽Bpro-pa(mm) | 32.0±4.2 | 29.3±3.7 | 5.28*** | 29.9±3.3 | 27.9±3.2 | 4.18*** | |
| 头围Che (mm) | 560.7±18.2 | 557.1±14.7 | 1.61 | 551.1±20.7 | 536.9±13.5 | 5.05*** | |
表4 畲族25~45岁成人的头面部指标比较(mm,$\bar{x}±s$)
Tab.4 Comparison of means and indices of craniofacial characteristics of adults aged 25~45 between She people
| 指标Index | 男性Male | 女性Female | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| n(2018)=85 | n(1996)=212 | t | n(2018)=61 | n(1996)=200 | t | ||
| 头长Lg-op(mm) | 181.0±12.2 | 187.2±6.0 | -4.46*** | 171.1±11.2 | 177.9±9.1 | -4.34*** | |
| 头宽Beu-eu(mm) | 145.2±11.8 | 146.4±6.3 | -0.86 | 137.5±10.7 | 140.0±5.7 | -1.74 | |
| 额最小宽Bft-ft(mm) | 116.0±10.7 | 105.1±5.9 | 8.83*** | 114.1±14.9 | 102.1±5.1 | 6.19*** | |
| 面宽Bzy-zy(mm) | 135.4±9.6 | 138.0±5.9 | -2.36* | 127.2±8.8 | 131.3±5.0 | -3.47*** | |
| 眼内角间宽Ben-en(mm) | 30.9±4.7 | 34.4±3.5 | -6.20*** | 28.0±4.3 | 32.8±3.2 | -8.21*** | |
| 眼外角间宽Bex-ex(mm) | 102.2±6.5 | 89.4±4.5 | 16.56*** | 98.4±6.7 | 85.7±4.4 | 13.96*** | |
| 鼻宽Ba-a(mm) | 38.7±5.4 | 37.8±2.9 | 1.42 | 36.4±3.0 | 34.8±5.2 | 3.02** | |
| 口宽Bch-ch(mm) | 50.0±4.7 | 52.2±4.3 | -3.70*** | 47.0±3.9 | 49.1±4.9 | -3.50*** | |
| 容貌面高Htr-gn(mm) | 181.6±11.3 | 188.9±8.9 | -5.34*** | 172.2±12.3 | 178.9±14.2 | -3.58*** | |
| 形态面高Hn-gn(mm) | 117.8±8.1 | 124.8±6.9 | -6.97*** | 111.9±8.9 | 118.0±6.5 | -4.96*** | |
| 鼻高Hn-sn(mm) | 52.4±6.0 | 55.5±3.8 | -4.40*** | 49.4±6.4 | 52.7±4.2 | -3.80*** | |
| 唇高Hls-li(mm) | 18.1±3.4 | 19.5±3.1 | -3.22** | 17.8±3.8 | 18.5±3.0 | -1.35 | |
| 容貌耳长Lsa-sba(mm) | 62.7±5.1 | 63.2±4.1 | -0.77 | 57.9±5.3 | 59.1±3.8 | -1.60 | |
| 容貌耳宽Bpro-pa(mm) | 32.0±4.2 | 29.3±3.7 | 5.28*** | 29.9±3.3 | 27.9±3.2 | 4.18*** | |
| 头围Che (mm) | 560.7±18.2 | 557.1±14.7 | 1.61 | 551.1±20.7 | 536.9±13.5 | 5.05*** | |
图2 福建畲族与其他群体头面部特征聚类图(男) 注:图1和2中比较数据依序来自参考文献[12-33]。The comparative data in Figures 1 and 2 are sourced from references 12-33 in order.
Fig.2 Cluster analysis of head and facial features of the She ethnic group in Fujian and other groups (male)
| [1] | 徐规. 畬族的名称、来源和迁徙[J]. 杭州大学学报(人文科学版), 1962, 1: 57-62 |
| [2] | 施联朱. 关于畲族来源与迁徙[J]. 中央民族学院学报, 1983, 2: 34-42+33 |
| [3] | 禄佳妮, 王传超. 分子人类学视域中畲族族源新探[J]. 北方民族大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2019, 1: 98-107 |
| [4] | Cai XY, Qin ZD, Wen B, et al. Human Migration through Bottlenecks from Southeast Asia into East Asia during Last Glacial Maximum Revealed by Y Chromosomes[J]. PLoS One, 2011, 6(8): e24282 |
| [5] |
Liu SH, Chen GC, Huang HH, et al. Patrilineal background of the She minority population from Chaoshan Fenghuang Mountain, an isolated mountain region, in China[J]. Genomics, 2017, 109(3-4): 284-289
doi: S0888-7543(17)30033-2 pmid: 28487173 |
| [6] | 胡荣. 福建畲族人群体型特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2021, 40(5): 824-833 |
| [7] | 张振标. 现代中国人体质特征及其类型的分析[J]. 人类学学报, 1988, 7(4): 314-323 |
| [8] | 徐杰舜. 雪球:汉民族的人类学分析[M]. 上海: 上海人民出版社, 1999 |
| [9] | 曾宪智, 戴福珍, 史习舜, 等. 福建省福安市畲族成人体质调查报告[J]. 福建医药杂志, 1996, 18(5): 211-216 |
| [10] | 孙思, 何学华, 曹显明, 等. 贵州南部地区苗族、畲族和汉族头面部形态特征调查[J]. 黔南民族医专学报, 2006, 19(3): 211-216 |
| [11] | 席焕久, 陈昭. 人体测量方法(第二版)[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2010 |
| [12] | 李咏兰, 宇克莉, 陆舜华, 等. 中国南方汉族群体的头面部特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2014, 33(1): 101-108 |
| [13] | 宇克莉, 郑连斌, 李咏兰, 等. 中国北方、南方汉族头面部形态学特征的差异[J]. 解剖学报, 2016, 47(3): 404-408 |
| [14] | 张兴华, 郑连斌, 宇克莉, 等. 闽南人的体质特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2015, 34(4): 516-527 |
| [15] | 郑连斌, 李咏兰, 陆舜华, 等. 中国客家人体质特征[J]. 中国科学:生命科学, 2013, 43(3): 213-222 |
| [16] | 孙泽阳, 郑连斌, 宇克莉, 等. 孟高棉语族未识别民族的体质特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2021, 40(5): 811-823 |
| [17] | 罗载刚, 杨家力, 余跃生, 等. 白裤瑶体质人类学研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2003, 22(2): 150-160 |
| [18] | 郑连斌, 陆舜华, 丁博. 仫佬族体质特征研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2006, 25(3): 242-250 |
| [19] | 余跃生, 任光祥, 戎聚全, 等. 贵州布依族体质人类学研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2005, 24(3): 204-214 |
| [20] | 余跃生, 王克松, 陆玉炯, 等. 贵州“过卯”水族的体质人类学研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2007, 26(2): 155-164 |
| [21] | 杨秀海, 余跃生, 欧德灯, 等. 贵州侗族体质人类学研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2010, 29(1): 73-81 |
| [22] | 余跃生, 陆玉炯, 罗载刚, 等. 贵州王卡苗族体质人类学研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2007, 26(1): 54-63 |
| [23] | 任光祥, 余跃生, 杨胜文, 等. 贵州土家族体质人类学研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2012, 31(3): 289-298 |
| [24] | 皮建辉, 黎杰, 李林, 等. 湖南瓦乡人体质特征研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2011, 30(2): 218-226 |
| [25] | 李明, 李跃敏, 余发昌, 等. 云南拉祜族的体质特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2001, 20(1): 39-44 |
| [26] | 宇克莉, 郑连斌, 李咏兰. 西双版纳傣族的人种学特点:来自人体测量学的数据[J]. 人类学学报, 2017, 36(4): 553-560 |
| [27] | 郑连斌, 陆舜华, 罗东梅, 等. 怒族的体质调查[J]. 人类学学报, 2008, 27(2): 158-166 |
| [28] | 包金萍, 郑连斌, 宇克莉, 等. 基诺族体质特征及35年来体质的变化[J]. 人类学学报, 2021, 40(2): 261-271 |
| [29] | 李咏兰, 郑连斌, 金丹. 黎族的体成分与体质特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2019, 38(1): 77-87 |
| [30] | 宇克莉, 董文静, 李咏兰. 四川凉山彝族的人体测量学[J]. 人类学学报, 2018, 37(3): 478-483 |
| [31] | 郑连斌, 崔静, 陆舜华, 等. 乌孜别克族体质特征研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2004, 23(1): 35-45 |
| [32] | 徐国昌, 马长德, 裴林国, 等. 伊犁锡伯族成人头面部表型特征[J]. 南阳理工学院学报, 2021, 13(4): 113-117 |
| [33] | 郑连斌, 陆舜华, 张兴华, 等. 珞巴族与门巴族的体质特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2009, 28(4): 401-407 |
| [34] | Reddy BM, Pferrer A, Crawford MH, et al. Population substructure and patterns of quantitative variation among the Gollas of southern Andhra Pradesh,India[J]. Human Biology, 2001, 291-306 |
| [35] |
Arya R, Duggirala R, Comuzzie AG. Heritability of anthropometric phenotypes in caste populations of Visakhapatnam, India[J]. Human Biology, 2002, 74(3): 325-344
pmid: 12180759 |
| [36] |
Karafet TM, Hallmark B, Cox MP, et al. Major East-west Division Underlies Y Chromosome Stratification Across Indonesia[J]. Molecular Biology and Evolution, 2010, 27(8): 1833-1844
doi: 10.1093/molbev/msq063 pmid: 20207712 |
| [1] | 宇克莉, 张兴华, 程智, 郑连斌. 中国不同人群的头面部特征及其差异[J]. 人类学学报, 2024, 43(04): 574-585. |
| [2] | 陈桐君, 相健美, 滕少康, 罗宝英, 黄仲庆, 李孝亮, 黄丽萍, 陈惠华, 谢继裕. 福建闽南地区汉族与畲族的指长比[J]. 人类学学报, 2022, 41(01): 51-56. |
| [3] | 宇克莉, 向小雪, 李咏兰, 张洪明, 杜慧敏. 中国夏尔巴人的体质特征研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2021, 40(05): 801-810. |
| [4] | 胡荣. 福建畲族人群体型特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2021, 40(05): 824-833. |
| [5] | 张实. 体质、生态与文化——对福建省罗源县八井村畲族体质的个案研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2010, 29(01): 82-87. |
| [6] | 杨若明,金继红. 对藏族、畲族、朝鲜族人发中微量元素的聚类分析研究[J]. 人类学学报, 2001, 20(02): 157-161. |
| [7] | 梅长华,俞雅琴,江三多,冯国鄞. 安徽省宁国县畲族群体HLA抗原分布[J]. 人类学学报, 2001, 20(01): 64-68. |
| [8] | 郭俊明,张文峰,钟为群,叶金花,缪春华,赖日勇,钟富有,黄功华. 用DNA多态性分析福建、江西和浙江3省畲族的亲缘关系[J]. 人类学学报, 1999, 18(02): 109-114. |
| [9] | 卓孝福,郭永建,戴庚孙,尹学念,徐玖瑾,杜若甫. 畲族Gc、PGM1、AcP1、6-PGD、ADA和AK1的遗传多态性[J]. 人类学学报, 1997, 16(04): 262-270. |
| [10] | 杨东亚. 甘肃汉族头面部特征亲子相关研究[J]. 人类学学报, 1989, 8(03): 255-260. |
| 阅读次数 | ||||||
|
全文 |
|
|||||
|
摘要 |
|
|||||
京ICP证05002819号-3