三种判定骨龄方法的比较

人类学学报 ›› 1993, Vol. 12 ›› Issue (03): 235-240.

三种判定骨龄方法的比较

孙殿军，王忠旭，高本

出版日期:1993-09-15 发布日期:1993-09-15

Study on the difference of this skeletal maturity assessed by three kinds of methods

Sun Dianjun, Wang Zhongxu, Gao Ben

Online:1993-09-15 Published:1993-09-15

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 我们运用李果珍“百分计数法”，哈尔滨医科大学制成的标准图谱法和Tanner-TW2 法对哈尔滨市553名7—12岁汉族小学生分别进行骨龄判定，比较了这三种方法估计骨龄的差异，结果表明：李果珍法判定骨龄比其余两种方法准确；图谱法估计的骨龄与李果珍法接近；TW2 法不适用于中国北方汉族儿童骨龄判定。

关键词: 学龄儿童；骨龄；TW2法

Abstract: Tanner--Whitehouse( TW2 )method, the Atlas method and Scorring system ( Li Guozhen ) skeletal age assessments were made in the school children sample of 275 males and 278 females aged 7--12 years in the Northern Chinese city of Harbin. The accuracy of skeletal age assessed respectively by three kinds of methods was compared each other. Wefound that Tanner-White house method was not fit for assessment of skeletal maturity onthe Northern Chinese school children of Han nationality. The Tanner- -White house skeletal ages were markedly greater than the corresponding chronological ages. The scorring systen( Li Guozhen ) skeletal ages were similar to the chronological ages as were Harbin Atlas skeletal ages.

Key words: School children; Skeletal maturity; TW2 method

孙殿军，王忠旭，高本. 三种判定骨龄方法的比较[J]. 人类学学报, 1993, 12(03): 235-240.

Sun Dianjun, Wang Zhongxu, Gao Ben. Study on the difference of this skeletal maturity assessed by three kinds of methods[J]. Acta Anthropologica Sinica, 1993, 12(03): 235-240.