山西大同恒源路墓地人类颅骨的形态变异
收稿日期: 2024-11-26
修回日期: 2025-02-27
网络出版日期: 2026-10-16
基金资助
大同北魏时期出土人骨的生物考古学研究(21-4-15-1400-107);国家社会科学基金青年项目——“山西朔州马邑汉墓群出土人骨研究”(20CKG022)
Morphology variability of human crania from the Hengyuan Road Cemetery, Datong of Shanxi
Received date: 2024-11-26
Revised date: 2025-02-27
Online published: 2026-10-16
本文通过对山西大同恒源路北魏墓地出土的人类颅骨进行形态学分析,探讨了墓地内个体颅骨形态的变异性及欧罗巴人种因素的存在。首先,结合主成分分析和生物距离分析评估组内颅骨形态的变异度,结果显示男性个体的变异度较低,而女性的变异度相对较高,暗示其来源的多样性。其次,采用判别分析方法与Howells数据库中的世界各地人群进行对比,初步判定部分个体可能具有欧罗巴人种的特征。再次,进一步鉴定出M35、M13-2等个体具有欧罗巴人种因素,且两性中的这些个体分别与欧罗巴人种的地中海东支类型和中亚两河类型较为接近。最后,通过生物距离构建无根邻接树,判断这些具有欧罗巴因素的个体与中国代表性古代人群的关系,推测这些欧罗巴人种因素可能与当时的文化交流、战争移民以及胡人迁居有关。本文不仅为北魏时期平城居民来源提供了新的证据,还验证了多元统计分析及机器学习算法在人种鉴定中的有效性,并且讨论了人种鉴定的意义。
侯侃 , 李树云 , 徐楠 , 李君 . 山西大同恒源路墓地人类颅骨的形态变异[J]. 人类学学报, 2026 , 45(05) : 896 -911 . DOI: 10.16359/j.1000-3193/AAS.2025.0054
Cranial morphological variability and potential European ancestry factors in human skeletal remains from the Northern Wei Dynasty cemetery at Hengyuan Road were examined in this study. A total of 62 craniums were analyzed, focusing on 18 male and 22 female adult individuals. The research aimed to address methodological limitations in traditional cranial analysis by integrating multivariate statistics and machine learning algorithms, thereby reducing subjectivity in ancestry estimation. The study began with an assessment of within-group variability using Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and biological distance analysis. Specifically, the mean pairwise Euclidean distance (dm) was calculated to quantify intra- and intergroup variation, revealing that male craniums exhibited significantly lower variability compared to females. This disparity suggests that females may have originated from more diverse genetic or geographic backgrounds, potentially linked to intermarriage or migration practices during the Northern Wei period.
To identify non-Mongoloid individuals, discriminant analysis was conducted using W. W. Howells’ global craniometric database. The results suggested the presence of Europoid traits in some individuals, particularly those resembling the Mediterranean East Type (e.g., M35) and the Central Asian-Two Rivers Type (e.g., M13-2), which are two branches of Europoid. Machine learning algorithms, including random forest (via Ancestrees) and linear discriminant analysis (via Fordisc 3.1), were employed to validate these findings. For instance, M13-2 exhibited a 77.73% probability of Northern / Central European ancestry using Ancestrees’ tournamentForest algorithm, while Fordisc classified M35 as closest to ancient Egyptian and Zalavar groups (probabilities: 34.9% and 31.2%, respectively). These results highlight the advantage of algorithmic approaches in mitigating observer bias inherent in traditional visual assessments.
Biological distance analysis using unrooted neighbor-joining trees further contextualized these individuals within broader Eurasian populations. M35 clustered closely with Mediterranean East Type groups (e.g., Alagou I and Shampula), historically associated with ancient Silk Road populations like the Cheshi and Yutian. Conversely, M13-2 aligned with Central Asian-Two Rivers Type groups (e.g., Jilintai and Zhaosu), suggesting ties to Wusun or Xiongnu-affiliated populations. Notably, the mixed ancestry observed in females like M8-1 and M38 may reflect the multicultural dynamics of Pingcheng (modern Datong), which served as a hub for trade, warfare, and religious exchange during the Northern Wei Dynasty.
The socio-political context of Pingcheng as a cosmopolitan center underpins these findings. Between the 4th and 6th centuries CE, the Northern Wei court relocated millions of people from conquered territories, including Central Asian, Xianbei, and Xiongnu groups. Additionally, the presence of Buddhist artifacts in the Hengyuan Road cemetery aligns with historical records of Sogdian and Persian monks contributing to religious dissemination, possibly introducing Europoid genetic lineages. This multicultural exchange is reflected in the coexistence of European and East Asian cranial traits within the burial population.
Finally, the study underscores the transformative potential of advanced statistical methods in bioarchaeology. By combining PCA, machine learning, and phylogenetic networks, this research provides a replicable framework for analyzing cranial variability and ancestry in fragmented or incomplete datasets. However, limitations such as missing data emphasize the need for cautious interpretation. This work not only enriches our understanding of population diversity in medieval China but also challenges historical narratives by demonstrating that Europoid individuals in the Yellow River Basin were likely isolated cases rather than large-scale migrants, consistent with Han Kangxin’s earlier conclusions. Ultimately, these findings illustrate how cultural assimilation and the Silk Road’s connectivity shaped the biological landscape of ancient Pingcheng, reaffirming the integrative power of Chinese civilization.
| [1] | Devor EJ. Transmission of human craniofacial dimensions[J]. Journal of Craniofacial Genetics and Developmental Biology, 1987, 7(2): 95-106 |
| [2] | Pearson K. Craniological notes: homogeneity and heterogeneity in collections of crania[J]. Biometrika, 1903, 2(3): 345-347 |
| [3] | Howells WW. Some uses of the standard deviation in anthropometry[J]. Human Biology, 1936, 8(4): 592-600 |
| [4] | Hefner JT. Cranial nonmetric variation and estimating ancestry[J]. Journal of Forensic Sciences, 2009, 54(5): 985-995 |
| [5] | Plemons AM, Hefner JT. Ancestry estimation using macromorphoscopic traits[J]. Academic Forensic Pathology, 2016, 6(3): 400-412 |
| [6] | Hefner JT, Emanovsky PD, Byrd J, et al. The value of experience, education, and methods in ancestry prediction[A]. In: Proceedings of the 59th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences[C]. Colorado Springs, CO: American Academy of Forensic Sciences, 2007: H64 |
| [7] | Nakhaeizadeh S, Dror IE, Morgan RM. Cognitive bias in forensic anthropology: visual assessment of skeletal remains is susceptible to confirmation bias[J]. Science and Justice, 2014, 54(3): 208-214 |
| [8] | Dunn RR, Spiros MC, Kamnikar KR, et al. Ancestry estimation in forensic anthropology: A review[J]. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Forensic Science, 2020, 2(4): e1369 |
| [9] | Flouri DE, Alifragki A, Gómez García-Donas J, et al. Ancestry estimation: advances and limitations in forensic applications[J]. Research and Reports in Forensic Medical Science, 2022, 12: 13-24 |
| [10] | Cunha E, Ubelaker DH. Evaluation of ancestry from human skeletal remains: a concise review[J]. Forensic Sciences Research, 2020, 5(2): 89-97 |
| [11] | Ousley SD. Forensic classification and biodistance in the 21st century: the rise of learning machines[A]. In: Pilloud MA, Hefner JT (Eds). Biological distance analysis: Forensic and bioarchaeological perspectives[M]. London: Elsevier Inc, 2016, 197-212 |
| [12] | 曹臣明. 平城附近鲜卑及北魏墓葬分布规律考[J]. 文物, 2016(5): 61-69 |
| [13] | 徐楠. 大同二中南校区墓地出土人骨研究[D]. 硕士学位论文, 太原: 山西大学, 2023 |
| [14] | 邵象清. 人体测量手册[M]. 上海: 上海辞书出版社, 1985, 34-44 |
| [15] | White TD, Folkens PA. The Human Bone Manual[M]. Burlington: Academic Press, 2005, 406-419 |
| [16] | Evteev AA, Staroverov NE, Potrakhov NN. Analytical techniques and software for the study of intragroup metric variation using principal component analysis[J]. Bulletins et mémoires de la Société d’Anthropologie de Paris, 2021, 33(1): 87-97 |
| [17] | Howells WW. Howells' craniometric data on the internet[J]. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 1996, 101(3): 441-442 |
| [18] | Howells WW. Skull Shapes and the Map[M]. Cambridge: Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology, Harvard University, 1989, 89-119 |
| [19] | Navega D, Coelho C, Vicente R, et al. AncesTrees: ancestry estimation with randomized decision trees[J]. International journal of legal medicine, 2015, 129(5): 1145-1153 |
| [20] | Ousley SD, Jantz RL. Fordisc 3 and statistical methods for estimating sex and ancestry[A]. In: Dirkmaat DC(Ed.). A companion to forensic anthropology[M]. London: Wiley-Blackwell, 2012, 311-329 |
| [21] | Jantz RL, Ousley SD. Introduction to Fordisc 3 and human variation statistics[A]. In: Langley NR, Tersigni-Tarrant MT(Eds). Forensic Anthropology: A Comprehensive Introduction (2nd edition)[M]. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, 2017, 255-270 |
| [22] | Darroch JN, Mosimann JE. Canonical and principal components of shape[J]. Biometrika, 1985, 72(2): 241-252 |
| [23] | Huson DH, Bryant D. Application of phylogenetic networks in evolutionary studies[J]. Molecular biology and evolution, 2006, 23(2): 254-267 |
| [24] | Howells WW. Cranial Variation in Man[M]. Papers of the Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology, Harvard University, Vol. 67. Cambridge: Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology, Harvard University, 1973, 170-187 |
| [25] | Pang J, Dong Y, Turner C, et al. Analysis of data consistency identifies measurement abnormality in Howells' craniometric test data set[J]. American Journal of Biological Anthropology, 2022, 179(4): 687-692 |
| [26] | Howells WW. Skull Shapes and the Map[M]. Cambridge: Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology, Harvard University, 1989, 45-70 |
| [27] | Littlefield A, Lieberman L, Reynolds LT, et al. Redefining race: the potential demise of a concept in physical anthropology [and comments and reply][J]. Current Anthropology, 1982, 23(6): 641-655 |
| [28] | Armelagos G, Goodman AH. Race, racism, and anthropology[A]. In: Goodman AH, Leatherman TL(Eds). Building a New Biocultural Synthesis: Political-Economic Perspectives on Human Biology[M]. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 1998, 359-378 |
| [29] | Fuentes A, Ackermann RR, Athreya S, et al. AAPA statement on race and racism[J]. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 2019, 169(3): 400-402 |
| [30] | Sauer NJ. Forensic anthropology and the concept of race: if races don't exist, why are forensic anthropologists so good at identifying them?[J]. Social Science & Medicine, 1992, 34(2): 107-111 |
| [31] | Ousley S, Jantz R, Freid D. Understanding race and human variation: why forensic anthropologists are good at identifying race[J]. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 2009, 139(1): 68-76 |
| [32] | Ousley S, Jantz RL, Hefner JT. From Blumenbach to Howells: the slow, painful emergence of theory through forensic race estimation[A]. In: Boyd CC, Boyd DC (Eds). Forensic Anthropology: Theoretical Framework and Scientific Basis[M]. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 2018, 67-97 |
| [33] | Bamshad M, Wooding S, Salisbury BA, et al. Deconstructing the relationship between genetics and race[J]. Nature reviews genetics, 2004, 5(8): 598-609 |
| [34] | Ross AH, Williams SE. Ancestry studies in forensic anthropology: back on the frontier of racism[J]. Biology, 2021, 10(7): 602 |
| [35] | 希安·琼斯. 族属的考古:构建古今的身份[M].译者:陈淳,沈辛成. 上海: 上海古籍出版社, 2017 |
| [36] | 梁云, 白劲松. 中国古代北方民族史·拓跋鲜卑卷[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2021, 22-33 |
| [37] | 韩康信. 塞、乌孙、匈奴和突厥之种族人类学特征[J]. 西域研究, 1992, 2: 3-23 |
| [38] | 朱泓. 人种学上的匈奴、鲜卑与契丹[J]. 北方文物, 1994(2): 7-13 |
| [39] | 杨军. 鲜卑人中白种人来源考[J]. 辽宁师范大学学报(社会科学版), 2007, 30(6): 108-111 |
| [40] | 陈琳国. 中古北方民族史探[M]. 北京: 商务印书馆, 2010, 445-467 |
| [41] | 路遇, 滕泽之. 中国人口通史(上)[M]. 北京: 中国社会科学出版社, 2015, 240-255 |
| [42] | 李凭. 北魏平城时代(第四版)[M]. 上海: 上海古籍出版社, 2023, 8 |
| [43] | 葛剑雄. 中国移民史·第二卷·先秦至魏晋南北朝时期[M]. 上海: 复旦大学出版社, 2022, 478-518 |
| [44] | 马永. 北魏平城时期族际通婚研究[J]. 云冈研究, 2022(6): 75-80 |
| [45] | 张庆捷. 民族汇聚与文明互动——北朝社会的考古学观察[M]. 北京: 商务印书馆, 2015, 349-368 |
| [46] | 王银田. 丝绸之路与北魏平城[J]. 暨南学报(哲学社会科学版), 2014, 36(1): 139-150 |
| [47] | 尚永琪. 北朝胡人与佛教的传播[J]. 吉林大学社会科学学报, 2006(2): 135-142 |
| [48] | 刘宁. 新疆地区古代居民的人种结构研究:以楼兰、乌孙、车师、回鹘为例[D].硕士学位论文, 长春: 吉林大学, 2010 |
| [49] | 韩康信. 中国境内考古发现的西方人种成分[A].见:韩康信.韩康信人类学文选韩康信人类学文选[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2017, 59-84 |
| [50] | 张银运, 吴秀杰, 刘武. 中国西北地区古代人群头骨的欧洲人种特征[J]. 人类学学报, 2013, 32(3): 274-279 |
/
| 〈 |
|
〉 |